HuaRenCa
返回论坛
日常交流

财务报表里主观成分这么多,投资人是怎么通过看报表来做判断的?

奋斗永无止尽
奋斗永无止尽

1周前

比如 financial intelligence 里写道,salary 既可以算作 product cost 从而减少 gross profit,也可以算作 R&D 从而不影响 gross profit:

Determining accruals and allocations nearly always entails making assumptions and estimates. Take your salary as an example. Say that you worked in June on a new product line and that the new line was introduced in July. Now the accountant determining the allocations has to estimate how much of your salary should be matched to the product cost (because you spent much of your time on those initial products) and how much should be charged to development costs (because you also worked on the original development of the product). She must also decide how to accrue for June versus July. Depending on how she answers questions such as these, she can dramatically change the appearance of the income statement. Product cost goes into cost of goods sold. If product costs go up, gross profit goes down—and gross profit is a key measure for assessing product profitability. Development costs, however, go into R&D, which is included in the operating expense section of the income statement and doesn’t affect gross profit at all.

既然如此,为什么投资人还会通过 financial statement 做出投资判断?他们是如何区分里面的水分和真实盈利能力?

6
279

评论 (6)

Your avatar
点击登录后即可评论
Arabella
Arabella1周前

工资在product cost和R&D之间怎么分,这个例子确实点到了关键。

会跳舞的仙人掌
会跳舞的仙人掌1周前

不同国家的会计准则对这种分摊要求会不会差很多?比如US GAAP和IFRS在R&D处理上就不太一样。

差点就倒了
差点就倒了1周前

核心还是看现金流和多年趋势,单看一期gross profit很容易被分摊假设带偏。管理层为什么要这样分、有没有动机,比数字本身更值得琢磨。

数字化时代
数字化时代1周前

先看会计政策附注和审计意见,再决定信多少。

微笑的平衡
微笑的平衡1周前

这个例子讲的是理论上的灵活性,但实际报表里分摊方法一般会披露,不知道有没有具体案例可以对照看看?

唐诗如画
唐诗如画1周前

到了季报截止日,分摊和应计往往要在很短时间里定下来,仓促之下估计偏差容易被放大。看年报时最好和上一年的假设对比一下,突然变化的地方多留个心眼。