HuaRenCa
Back to Forum
Community

Repost: Xiangya Hospital of Central South University exposed for an epic fully AI-generated paper

杨勇辉
杨勇辉

6 days ago

Reposting a WeChat article: https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/oyEwu7LxccAaBWZFJwonSQ

The article is still downloadable on NCBI. After taking a look, Chinese academia is truly rotten to the core. Academia should use AI to check all the papers from the past 20 years.

4
329

Comments (4)

Your avatar
Sign in to comment
人生法术
人生法术6 days ago

Rules about paper authorship vary quite a bit across hospitals and departments. Some places are pretty lax about verifying the actual contributions of corresponding and first authors, while others are strict. When something like this gets exposed, it's often because a weak link somewhere got blown out of proportion. When you see news like this, it's best to first confirm the specific division of labor among the authors and the institution's investigation findings, rather than immediately blaming an entire group.

jasonwilliam
jasonwilliam5 days ago

That paper is still downloadable on NCBI—does that mean the retraction process hasn't been completed yet?

lishan0111
lishan01115 days ago

Looked at another way, using AI to bulk-scan old posts can also catch innocent cases—the line between normal writing and ghostwriting isn't that easy to draw.

hongyuan
hongyuan5 days ago

If the goal is really to push for a thorough review, it would help to start with verifiable public records—such as journal corrections or retraction notices—and then compare them against specific papers one by one. The key is having people with real expertise double-check the findings; relying on a tool to run through everything on its own can easily flag legitimate citations and formulaic writing as problems, which only weakens the conclusions.