I haven't seen any other similar DPs on the forum. I've only heard that Strata is now once-per-lifetime for the bonus. But I've never applied for Strata before. In the past I only applied for one AA Platinum. What's going on?

I haven't seen any other similar DPs on the forum. I've only heard that Strata is now once-per-lifetime for the bonus. But I've never applied for Strata before. In the past I only applied for one AA Platinum. What's going on?

You've only ever applied for the AA Platinum and never touched the Strata, so this shouldn't trigger the once-in-a-lifetime restriction. Could it be that the pre-qualification page simply doesn't show the bonus, and there's actually a separate offer once the card is approved?
Looking at it from another angle, lifetime rewards are usually calculated per specific card type, so this probably has nothing to do with the AA Platinum. More likely, the pre-qualification system only determines eligibility and doesn't display rewards, or the card you're looking at is simply a version that doesn't come with a sign-up bonus—so your application history likely isn't the main factor here.
Before you apply, call customer service first to confirm which rewards you're eligible for—don't just rely on the pre-approval page.
Passing pre-screening doesn't guarantee a reward once you click through—the offer terms may change at the actual submission stage, so it's best to take a screenshot for your records before you apply.
The key question is still whether pre-review approval and reward eligibility are two separate systems.