HuaRenCa
Back to Forum
Community

[Shitpost] Claude isn't suited for everyday questions, especially about food

facasyji
facasyji

1 week ago

Here's a rather unscientific test I ran.

Prompt: Give me a few recipes for cooking dinner tonight.

Fable 5.2:

Here are three quick home-style dishes that come together as a full meal in about 40 minutes total (serves 2–3).

  1. Tomato and Egg Stir-Fry (10 minutes)

Ingredients: 2 tomatoes, 3 eggs, chopped scallions, salt, 1 tsp sugar

Method:

Beat the eggs with a pinch of salt, stir-fry in hot oil until just set, then remove.

Cut the tomatoes into chunks and stir-fry over medium heat until they release their juices, then add sugar and salt.

Return the eggs to the pan, toss to combine, scatter with scallions, and serve.

  1. Cola Chicken Wings (25 minutes)

Ingredients: 8–10 chicken wing mid-joints, 1 can cola (330ml), 2 tbsp light soy sauce, ½ tbsp dark soy sauce, 3 slices ginger

Method:

Score each wing twice on both sides, blanch in cold water, then drain.

Sear the wings in a little oil until golden on both sides, then add the ginger slices.

Pour in the cola, light soy sauce, and dark soy sauce, bring to a boil over high heat, then reduce to medium-low and simmer for 15 minutes.

Turn up the heat and reduce the sauce until thick, coating the wings evenly.

  1. Garlic Broccoli (8 minutes)

Ingredients: 1 head broccoli, 4–5 cloves garlic, salt, 1 tbsp oyster sauce

Method:

Break the broccoli into small florets, blanch in boiling water with a pinch of salt and a little oil for 1 minute, then drain.

Heat oil and sauté the minced garlic until fragrant, add the broccoli, and stir-fry over high heat for 1 minute.

Season with oyster sauce and salt, then serve.

Start the rice first, then make the wings, and while they simmer, make the other two dishes so everything can go on the table at once.

What ingredients do you have at home, or do you have any flavor preferences (spicy, light, etc.)? Let me know and I can swap in dishes that suit you better.

Gemini free/auto:

If you want a weeknight dinner that's both quick and tasty while also being high in protein, low in saturated fat, and rich in dietary fiber, you can try this combination: one main dish, one quick stir-fried vegetable, and one soup/egg dish—a balanced mix of meat and vegetables with well-rounded nutrition.

  1. Main dish: Pan-seared/roasted salmon (or chicken breast) with seasonal asparagus

Features: Rich in high-quality protein and healthy Omega-3 fatty acids; extremely simple to make and ready in just over ten minutes.

Method:

Rinse the salmon (or chicken breast) and pat dry with paper towels; rub the surface with a little salt, black pepper, and rosemary.

Heat a pan with a little oil (a spray bottle works well), sear the salmon skin-side down over medium-low heat until crisp, then flip and cook for another 2–3 minutes until just cooked through.

Cut the asparagus into segments and briefly blanch/stir-fry using the residual oil in the pan or a little water, then plate.

  1. Quick stir-fried vegetable: Zucchini with eggs (or garlic broccoli)

Features: Rich in dietary fiber and vitamins, low-calorie and filling, fresh and not greasy.

Method:

Cut the zucchini into thin half-moon slices and beat the eggs.

Heat the pan with oil, pour in the beaten eggs, scramble until just set, and remove.

Add a little more oil to the pan, sauté sliced garlic until fragrant, add the zucchini slices, and stir-fry until slightly softened.

Return the scrambled eggs to the pan, season with salt and a little light soy sauce, toss evenly, and serve.

  1. Soup/light dish: Shrimp, mushroom, and tofu soup

Features: Savory and low-fat, high in protein, warming and completely guilt-free.

Method:

Rinse the shrimp and remove the veins; cut the mushrooms (such as white jade mushrooms or crab mushrooms) into segments; cut the soft tofu into small cubes.

Heat a little oil in a pot, sauté scallions and mushrooms until fragrant and slightly softened.

Add an appropriate amount of boiling water, add the tofu cubes, and cook for 3 minutes, then add the shrimp.

Once the shrimp turn red and are cooked through, season with a little salt and white pepper, scatter with scallions, and serve.

The video below demonstrates quick weeknight cooking techniques and healthy flavor combinations.

10:15

5 Instant Favorite HIGH-PROTEIN Dinners | Quick, Cheap & EASY Healthy Summer Meals | Julia Pacheco

YouTube · Julia Pacheco

15:37

5 High-Protein Dinner Recipes You Need to Try | Allrecipes

YouTube · Allrecipes

9:07

The one-pan protein dinner I make every week (healthy and anti-inflammatory)

YouTube · The Doctor's Kitchen

Deepseek 4.1 flash:

Sure—here's a set for two to three people, ready to eat within an hour: 3 dishes and 1 soup, no difficulty, built around "start with the time-consuming stuff and finish with quick stir-fries." I'll also use Fahrenheit since that's what you're used to.

Tonight's menu

① Air-fryer honey chicken wings (main dish, marinate first)

Ingredients: 8–10 chicken wing mid-joints, 2 tbsp light soy sauce, 1 tbsp oyster sauce, 1 tbsp honey, 1 tsp minced garlic, 1 tsp cooking wine, black pepper

Method: Score the surface of the wings twice, mix with all the seasonings, and marinate for 15 minutes (5 minutes is fine if you're in a hurry). Air-fry at 380°F for 12 minutes, flipping once halfway through; finally brush on a layer of "honey and light soy sauce" and air-fry at 400°F for another 3 minutes to glaze.

② Tomato and egg stir-fry (goes great with rice)

Ingredients: 2 tomatoes, 3 eggs, 1 tsp sugar, salt

Key points: Add a teaspoon of water to the beaten eggs; use a bit more oil in a hot pan and stir-fry until just set, then remove. Stir-fry the tomatoes until they break down, add sugar and salt, return the eggs to the pan, toss for 30 seconds, and turn off the heat. Peeling the tomatoes first makes a big difference in texture.

③ Garlic stir-fried greens (bok choy, yu choy, or broccoli all work)

Ingredients: 400g greens, 3 cloves garlic, salt, a few drops of oyster sauce

Key points: Cook over high heat for 2 minutes the whole time; add the minced garlic in two batches—half to sauté until fragrant, half scattered in just before serving. Don't add water; the steam in the pan is enough.

④ Seaweed egg-drop soup (last 8 minutes)

Ingredients: a small handful of seaweed, 1 egg, dried shrimp or scallions, salt, white pepper, sesame oil

Key points: After the water boils, turn to low heat before drizzling in the egg; wait 10 seconds, then gently stir to break it up. Add the seaweed last—it turns bitter if cooked too long.

Timeline (assuming you start at 18:00)

Time Action

18:00 Rinse rice and start cooking; marinate the wings

18:15 Put the wings in the air fryer at 380°F

18:20 Cut the tomatoes, beat the eggs, wash the greens

18:27 Stir-fry tomato and egg

18:30 Flip the wings and finish the last 3 minutes

18:38 Stir-fry the greens over high heat

18:43 Make the soup

18:50 Dinner is served

If you want to change direction

Only 20 minutes: tomato and egg noodles, or garlic egg fried rice, plus seaweed soup—one pot all the way.

Want more meat: Swap the wings for black pepper beef strips (beef strips only need 90 seconds of stir-frying) or pan-seared salmon (skin-side down at 400°F).

Guests coming: Add an air-fryer garlic spare ribs dish you're familiar with, or the squirrel fish from last time—you already have experience with both.

All air-fryer lazy mode: Alternate the wings and roasted vegetables (broccoli, bell peppers, button mushrooms, 400°F for 10 minutes) in the air fryer, leaving just one burner for the soup.

If you tell me how many people are eating, any dietary restrictions, and what's in the fridge, I can adjust this into a version with exactly no leftovers.

【Shitpost】Claude isn't suited for everyday questions, especially about food

6
296

Comments (6)

Your avatar
Sign in to comment
bobi
bobi1 week ago

For recipe information like this, it's best to state clearly whether it was generated directly by a model or compiled by a person, because if the seasoning ratios or cooking-time descriptions are off, following them can easily lead to a failed dish. If it's just a personal test record, it's advisable to frame the conclusions as "for reference only" rather than treating them as a standard answer.

舟际
舟际1 week ago

Actually, this is more about comparing how different models respond stylistically to open-ended cooking instructions, rather than judging who is better at cooking.

75333ucs0q
75333ucs0q1 week ago

If your kitchen has limited burners or no air fryer, Deepseek's timeline is a bit too idealistic—especially when you're making chicken wings and stir-frying at the same time, it's easy to get overwhelmed. Also, Fahrenheit isn't very user-friendly for non-US users; switching to Celsius or noting the conversion would be more practical. And you really do need to ask about the number of people and dietary restrictions upfront—otherwise, even the most detailed recommendations may be useless.

2951a628fa6d
2951a628fa6d6 days ago

Deepseek singles out peeling the tomatoes first, and that detail really does make a big difference to the texture, though a lot of quick recipes skip it. That said, marinating the chicken wings for just 5 minutes before they go into the air fryer probably won't get them as flavorful as 15 minutes would, so it's best to make clear that this is a quick-fix option.

坨骡
坨骡6 days ago

The timeline is too tight—the actual time needed for washing, chopping, and cleaning up the stove is often underestimated.

谁与争风
谁与争风6 days ago

The core issue isn't which model offers more complete recipes, but whether "everyday queries" really call for quick, actionable answers or comprehensive nutrition. Fable's approach fits the scenario of wanting to get food on the table as fast as possible after work—steps and quantities are kept very short. Gemini emphasizes balanced nutrition and ingredient variety, but once you bring in videos and soups, the practical effort and shopping requirements go up. To make the discussion more valuable, you could first break "everyday questions" into dimensions like time budget, ingredients on hand, dietary restrictions, and kitchen equipment, then see which type of answer fits each case, rather than comparing them broadly as better or worse.