I always thought Flighty's delay info was accurate, and I even paid a hefty sum for a membership. But a delay that was known well in advance still hasn't synced to Flighty even though it's almost the original departure time—it's not even as good as Google...
And this is definitely not the first time. I'm never giving them my money again.

I'd like to check where you saw the "delay that had been showing for a while." If you first saw it on the airline's official website or an airport display board, then Flighty may indeed have lagged in syncing its data source—but it's also possible that the flight status it pulled isn't for the same linked flight you actually operated, for example due to a codeshare or a flight number change. These situations can feel a lot like "inaccurate," but the reasons are somewhat different.