HuaRenCa
Back to Forum
Community

Got the HomeView, but It's a Bit Disappointing

cece321
cece321

1 week ago

Let me start with the pros:

Looks great

Sound quality is better than expected (though I'm easy to please—just need it to make noise)

Now for the cons:

  1. The screen feels pretty small, probably because of the aspect ratio.

  2. The system is simpler than I expected—even less capable than watchOS, and far less fun to tinker with.

  3. If you want to link it with your phone, they have to be on the same Wi-Fi. All my IoT devices are on a separate Wi-Fi network, and my original HomePod is on that network too—that way I can conveniently control my smart devices while keeping the networks separated. Now if I want to use HomeView's linking feature, I'd have to connect my phone to the IoT Wi-Fi. You might ask why not just connect HomeView to the main Wi-Fi—because when it does, it stupidly takes all my IoT devices offline. Bur, what are you even doing, HomePod?

  4. To be continued

4
627

Comments (4)

Your avatar
Sign in to comment
杨俊笙
杨俊笙1 week ago

It seems this product still isn't very polished—the crude system and ecosystem integration issues affect the experience more than the hardware itself does. Separating the networks is a sensible approach, but requiring devices to be on the same Wi-Fi for integration is a real drawback; it essentially forces users to choose between security isolation and full functionality. I'd suggest focusing your follow-up testing on whether firmware updates can improve this logic. If it stays this way, the product's positioning will be rather awkward.

我在线我精彩
我在线我精彩1 week ago

You mentioned that when HomeView connects to the main Wi-Fi, it takes all the IoT devices offline. Does this happen every time, or only occasionally? Also, after your phone reconnects to the IoT Wi-Fi, do the automation features work normally across all scenes? Once we confirm these two details, we should be able to tell whether it's a software bug or a design logic issue.

sdxzxzyt1
sdxzxzyt11 week ago

Regarding the simplicity of the system—is there any chance it could later be extended through firmware or plugins? Otherwise, it would indeed be hard to make up for the lack of flexibility.

胡雪岩
胡雪岩6 days ago

The most noteworthy point is that network separation gets broken. You originally put IoT on a separate Wi-Fi to isolate risk, but now to enable integration you have your phone switching back and forth between networks, which effectively exposes your phone to the IoT subnet—not a great trade-off in the long run. And the fact that HomeView kicks devices offline when connected to the main network suggests its discovery mechanism may rely on broadcast or mDNS, which fails across subnets. If you have many smart devices at home, this design will force you into constant compromises on network architecture. I'd suggest trying it on a small scale first rather than rushing to migrate all your core devices over.