HuaRenCa
Back to Forum
Community

Rejected by BoA Three Times in One Year, Each Time with a New Reason

东京尤里71134
东京尤里71134

1 week ago

I've had a BoA Checking account for ten years, and the BBR card was my second credit card after Discover. I watched that beloved card get converted to the 123, and my relationship with BoA has been lukewarm over the years—the Checking account stayed open, the card stayed active, but I rarely bothered to give BoA my business.

Things changed this year. After Amex and Chase had both entered sage mode with no good cards left to apply for, the Alaska Summit came onto my radar. Given my friendly history with Amex and Chase, I figured BoA would be a piece of cake too. So I bravely applied in June—and immediately got my first rejection in years. The reason was straightforward enough: there was a collection on my credit report that had been disputed but hadn't disappeared yet. Knowing I was in the wrong, I slunk away with my tail between my legs. The recon rep was actually quite nice, saying I could try again after my credit report was corrected.

In July, I finally resolved that annoying collection and felt I had a chance to "start fresh." So I tried again—only to be rejected once more. This time the reason was that I'd applied within the past 30 days, and that I didn't have enough funds with BoA. I was a bit resentful but could accept it—after all, I'd neglected BoA for too long.

In November, the 100k offer appeared, and it happened to coincide with my release from 5/24. After MDD-ing two Chase cards, I felt confident again and angrily deposited two bricks into BoA. After letting it sit for a week, I decided to muster up the courage for a third attempt—instant denial. I called 5411 for recon, and this time there were more reasons—four in total: 1. Credit history too short 2. Too many cards with BoA 3. Recently opened a car lease 4. Too much credit extended by other banks. This was infuriating—reasons 1 and 2 weren't even true. Eleven years of credit history, and just one BoA card. And what the hell was reason 3? I escalated to a human, and the rep Karen (yes, actually named Karen) said she'd try some other methods for me and would get back to me in two days. But four days passed with no word. I called 5411 again to escalate, and was told it still wasn't possible—same four reasons, and they explicitly said I'd opened five cards in the past 24 months.

On a Friday no less, I was worn down to the point of having no temper left. BoA, loving you is really hard.

3
1.2K

Comments (3)

Your avatar
Sign in to comment
westpanda
westpanda1 week ago

Handling procedures may vary between branch locations, so it's best to confirm the specific requirements with your local branch first.

民航集团
民航集团1 week ago

Customer service said five cards were opened in 24 months, but that number doesn't quite line up with the 5/24 release timeline. Have you checked the account opening records on your credit report yourself? It might be that one card's reporting date is calculated differently.

胭脂淡泊
胭脂淡泊6 days ago

The rejection reasons contradict each other, which suggests the manual review standards aren't consistent. Still, of the four reasons, the one about the credit limit being too high is the most concrete—lowering the limit or waiting a few months for the new account to build history before trying again might be more effective.