HuaRenCa
Back to Forum
Community

Just started as an AP. The first student I recruited is really a headache...

axiommark123
axiommark123

1 week ago

This semester I sent out my first student offer, and they'll be starting next semester.

When we talked before, I said I hoped we could have regular meetings before they enroll—nothing demanding, just discussing interesting recent papers and hot topics, and then talking about what they'd work on after arriving... Before the offer was sent, they agreed to everything enthusiastically. But once the offer was actually sent, we've only met two or three times so far, and all the other meetings were postponed for various reasons—needing to prepare a camera-ready, feeling unwell, being on vacation, or even just straight-up no-showing. Then today they said that due to health reasons plus wanting to try something new, they want to cancel all the remaining meetings.

I only have two PhD student slots that I can directly nominate...

Sigh

7
1.1K

Comments (7)

Your avatar
Sign in to comment
风影彩云
风影彩云1 week ago

The core issue isn't that the student is lazy—it's that you never aligned your expectations for this relationship before enrollment. You see regular discussions as a test of commitment, while the other party may just be being polite. With so few slots, you should have made your bottom line crystal clear before the offer.

掐趾神蒜
掐趾神蒜1 week ago

When he said yes, did he make it clear that this is a hard requirement after admission, or was it just a casual remark?

麦小贱
麦小贱1 week ago

From another perspective, North American PhD students typically have a gap over the summer before enrollment, and many prioritize wrapping up graduation, visa, or family matters—it's not necessarily a question of attitude. But given that there are only two slots, you do need to reassess the return on your investment.

狂野曲麻莱
狂野曲麻莱1 week ago

Many advisors treat pre-enrollment contact as a two-way screening period, and it's common for students to express hesitation through delay. Rather than dwelling on whether he's going back on his word, consider whether he might be using health reasons as a polite way to decline.

上善若土
上善若土1 week ago

If he's still in this state later on, would you consider having a formal conversation about whether he stays or leaves before enrollment?

华彦
华彦1 week ago

The biggest thing to watch is the time cost: every time you schedule a meeting you have to block out time, and a single no-show wastes half a day. With only two slots available, if you wait until the semester starts to deal with it, the window to swap in a replacement is basically closed.

shengcaiyoudao
shengcaiyoudao6 days ago

I'd suggest sending a written confirmation first that clearly sets out the minimum expected frequency of communication before enrollment and the consequences of absence, then arranging a short meeting. This only makes sense if you're genuinely willing to give a second chance—otherwise it's better to make a decision sooner.