One-sentence summary: The hotel is tiny, the food is mediocre, and I probably won't be back.
Booked with a Diamond FN, two guests, upgraded to Deluxe Ocean Front in advance.
After check-in, the concierge personally walked us to the room, but the key card wouldn't open the door. We were forced to make awkward small talk at the door for 10 minutes—yeah, OP and P2 are both introverts.
By North American standards the room is pretty standard, but the hair dryer exceeded expectations.
All-inclusive:
Daily minibar refill: pop, juice, beer
Three restaurants: breakfast and lunch at Chaya, dinner at the Mexican restaurant J'AO and the seafood restaurant Malpeque. The all-inclusive only allows three courses, but in practice ordering extra didn't cost anything more.
The menu is stingy—the most valuable item is the New York steak, and it's only 9oz. Lobster, crab, and ribeye all cost extra.
The pattern is basically fixed: assorted ceviche to start, plus a soup/pasta/small seafood dish, steak or lamb chops for the main, dessert to finish. The grilled octopus, catch of the day, tacos, and Chaya's chocolate cake were pretty good.
Facilities: The hotel only has two pools, and you can walk around the whole property in 5 minutes. It really is small, and really is boring.
The Park Hyatt next door








It's less about the hotel being bad and more about the gap between what you expect from all-inclusive and what you actually get—you should check before booking which dishes cost extra.