HuaRenCa
Back to Forum
Community

Some consumer stocks I've held heavily in recent years

欧成文
欧成文

1 week ago

Since I started churning credit cards, I've gradually begun paying attention to some consumer stocks, especially thinking about which companies can weather cycles. But this year I've noticed consumer stocks (the old guard) and tech stocks show a very clear negative correlation. When tech rises, consumer falls; when consumer rises, tech is falling. Since most of my individual stock picks are consumer names and my ETF holdings are mainly QQQ, my account has been stuck going nowhere—especially with the recent semiconductor crash, while consumer hit new highs...

COST

BRKB

V

AXP, AKA the greatest company

KO

There are also some consumer stocks with less pleasant holding experiences, like MCD and DPZ—I feel like buying more once they get a bit cheaper

7
1.6K

Comments (7)

Your avatar
Sign in to comment
张生
张生1 week ago

When you discuss "riding through cycles" and "negative correlation" together, there's a premise that may not have been fully unpacked: is the negative correlation a long-term, stable relationship, or just a feature of this year's market moves? If it's only short-term rotation, hedging with consumer staples and QQQ may not be effective—you could end up missing out on both sides. Also, valuations for names like COST and KO aren't exactly low, so whether you'd actually dare to buy when they're cheap is another question entirely.

Daniel2022
Daniel20221 week ago

The logic behind domestic consumer stocks and US consumer stocks is quite different, so the companies you come across through credit card churning may not necessarily apply.

黑妞儿
黑妞儿1 week ago

You mentioned that MCD and DPZ want to wait for cheaper prices before buying—so specifically, are you looking at valuation percentiles, dividend yield, or same-store sales growth? Also, after consumption hits a new high, would you consider trimming a bit or continue holding?

喜欢凉风
喜欢凉风1 week ago

The core takeaway seems to be that consumer and tech are rotating, and the account is being pulled in both directions, which is why it's stuck in the middle. That observation makes sense, but you need to pin down the time window and the comparison benchmark; otherwise, "negative correlation" can easily be exaggerated by a few individual months. If you could add historical correlation data or at least specify the observation period, the conclusion would be more solid.

所想如愿
所想如愿1 week ago

If the account volatility is what's bothering you, first work out the respective position sizes of your consumer holdings and QQQ, then adjust.

田学兵
田学兵1 week ago

Strictly speaking, BRKB isn't really a pure consumer stock, and AXP leans more financial, so when comparing them with KO and COST, it's best to clarify what kind of "consumer exposure" you're actually after. Also, negative correlation can break down in extreme market conditions, so the boundary conditions are worth reconsidering.

夕游记
夕游记1 week ago

As a next step, you could pull the monthly returns for these stocks and QQQ over the past few years and calculate the correlations yourself, rather than judging rotation by gut feel. At the same time, write down your buy rationale and valuation range for each stock, so that when MCD and DPZ actually fall to your target prices, you can check them against your notes and avoid hesitating again at that point.