Applied for Chase while at 5/24, but reconsideration kept failing—the underwriter was very polite and said my total credit was too high. Looking at it, I really don't think the IHG Premier is worth keeping.
Comments (7)
Before your annual fee comes due, do the math—don't keep the card just to avoid the fee and end up paying it before you cancel.
High credit limits really do have different effects in different regions—some states' banks are more sensitive to your total credit exposure, while others care more about how deep your relationship is with them. First, check how much of your credit limit Chase counts the IHG card as using. If it's only a few thousand dollars, cutting it may not help as much with 5/24 as you'd think.
When you say the recon keeps failing, are you talking to a different underwriter each time, or going back and forth within the same round? Also, have you tried lowering the credit limits on your other cards before recon? In practice, that move often gets stuck because frontline reps don't have the authority to do it.
At the end of the day, it comes down to whether you can actually use the benefits this card offers. If you can't, it's time to reassess.
I'd actually hold off on closing it just yet. Yes, the IHG card has an annual fee, but if you get a free night each year, it may not end up being a net loss. Also, when the underwriter says your total credit is too high, they may not mean this one card specifically—it could be an issue with your overall credit structure. Closing one card may have limited impact on future applications, and you'd be giving up the length of your credit history for nothing.
Look at it from a different angle: maybe the question isn't whether to keep this card, but rather the timing and order of your Chase applications. Lowering your total credit limit first and then trying again in a few months may be more effective than agonizing over which card to close right now.
How exactly does the underwriter say the total credit is too high—do they look at the total limit or the limits on certain cards? Roughly how many cards do you have and what's your total credit line, if you don't mind sharing?