HuaRenCa
Back to Forum
Community

financial statement 里面主观成分这么多,投资人是如何通过看 statement 来做判断的?

奋斗永无止尽
奋斗永无止尽

1 week ago

比如说 financial intelligence 里面写道,salary 既可以当成 product cost 从而减少 gross profit,也可以当成 R&D 从而不影响 gross profit:

Determining accruals and allocations nearly always entails making assumptions and estimates. Take your salary as an example. Say that you worked in June on a new product line and that the new line was introduced in July. Now the accountant determining the allocations has to estimate how much of your salary should be matched to the product cost (because you spent much of your time on those initial products) and how much should be charged to development costs (because you also worked on the original development of the product). She must also decide how to accrue for June versus July. Depending on how she answers questions such as these, she can dramatically change the appearance of the income statement. Product cost goes into cost of goods sold. If product costs go up, gross profit goes down—and gross profit is a key measure for assessing product profitability. Development costs, however, go into R&D, which is included in the operating expense section of the income statement and doesn’t affect gross profit at all.

既然如此,为什么投资人还会通过 financial statement 做出投资判断?他们是如何区分里面的水分和真实盈利能力?

6
279

Comments (6)

Your avatar
Sign in to comment
Arabella
Arabella1 week ago

How wages are split between product cost and R&D—this example really hits the key point.

会跳舞的仙人掌
会跳舞的仙人掌1 week ago

Do accounting standards in different countries vary much in their allocation requirements? For example, US GAAP and IFRS handle R&D quite differently.

差点就倒了
差点就倒了1 week ago

Ultimately, it comes down to cash flow and multi-year trends. Looking at a single period's gross profit can easily be skewed by allocation assumptions. Why management chooses to allocate the way they do—and whether they have an incentive to—is more worth scrutinizing than the numbers themselves.

数字化时代
数字化时代1 week ago

Start with the accounting policy notes and the audit opinion, then decide how much to trust it.

微笑的平衡
微笑的平衡1 week ago

This example illustrates flexibility in theory, but in practice the allocation method is usually disclosed in the financial statements. I wonder if there are any specific cases we could compare against?

唐诗如画
唐诗如画1 week ago

When quarterly reporting deadlines arrive, allocations and accruals often have to be finalized in a very short window, and under that time pressure estimation errors can easily be magnified. When reviewing annual reports, it's best to compare the assumptions with those of the prior year and pay extra attention to any areas that have changed abruptly.