HuaRenCa
Back to Forum
Community

5/24 Applied for Boundless, Smoothly Denied — Not Sure If Recon Will Succeed

a96893
a96893

1 week ago

First card 2y3m, BOA 123, no SSN, $10,000 CL.

Got my SSN this February, submitted it to BOA, FICO 780.

Second card this June, US BANK UAC, $2,500 CL.

Third card this July, applied for CFU in branch, $8,400 CL, used it for two months and they increased me to $12,200 CL.

Fourth card this August, C1VX, $10,000 CL.

Fifth card 11.4, saw a 100k points black car and applied for CSP, instant approval, $11,000 CL (regretting it deeply!!!)

Right after applying I saw the Boundless elevated offer and really couldn't resist, applied on 11.10, happily got an EX HP. 11.11 got another TU HP, called and it turned out to be a holiday with no human reps working. This morning just as I was about to call, I got an email from Chase — opened it and saw I was denied, reason being oldest account not long enough. No choice but to call 8630, prepared a bunch of talking points — that it's almost holiday season and I'm planning to stay at hotels, that I'm willing to reallocate credit from other cards to Boundless — but before I could say anything the rep asked if I wanted a recon, so I just said yes, and they told me to keep waiting. Don't know if it'll go through, I'm ready for a second recon

5/24 Applied for Boundless, Smoothly Denied — Not Sure If Recon Will Succeed

5/24 Applied for Boundless, Smoothly Denied — Not Sure If Recon Will Succeed

5/24 Applied for Boundless, Smoothly Denied — Not Sure If Recon Will Succeed

7
43

Comments (7)

Your avatar
Sign in to comment
用户粟恩樂逸
用户粟恩樂逸1 week ago

The fact that customer service asked whether you want to recon instead of just rejecting you outright suggests there may still be some room to negotiate. That said, "oldest account isn't long enough" is a real concern—2 years and 3 months is indeed on the short side, and Chase is quite sensitive about credit history length, especially since you've opened several new cards recently. If the recon succeeds or you need to call again, could you update us on how it goes?

翰墨九州
翰墨九州1 week ago

When you called customer service, did they mention which specific card's credit report they needed to check?

nkuiapuemk
nkuiapuemk1 week ago

When you do the recon, it's best to have an explanation ready for why you've opened so many cards recently—otherwise the rep might question why you opened two Chase cards back-to-back in November.

yuf
yuf1 week ago

Actually, a 2-year-3-month oldest account isn't especially short, but the issue is that your card-opening pace this year has been too dense—five cards from February to November. When Chase sees that many new accounts, it may be more wary of that than of your oldest account. During recon, if you can clearly explain the purpose of each of these cards, that may be more persuasive than emphasizing your hotel needs.

xianyou
xianyou1 week ago

Applying for the Boundless just a few days after the CSP gets instantly approved—that short a gap really does tend to trigger a review.

乡妹子
乡妹子1 week ago

You mentioned that you got the BOA 123 card without an SSN and only received your SSN later. In that case, could there be a delay when the bank matches your credit record? It feels like the report the customer service rep sees during recon might not be exactly the same as the one you check yourself.

十年盘一石
十年盘一石1 week ago

Judging from the denial reasons, the oldest account not being long enough is a real problem, and overturning it through recon won't be easy, but the fact that the rep proactively asked whether you wanted to do a recon suggests the door isn't completely closed. The key is to convince the rep that even though you've opened a lot of cards, your risk is manageable—for example, by emphasizing your clean repayment history and willingness to move credit limits around. That said, beyond 5/24, Chase has its own new-account restrictions, so talking points alone may not be enough.