HuaRenCa
Back to Forum
Community

The Three US Stock Giants Chosen by a Mud-Pit Newbie

看到回复上课
看到回复上课

1 week ago

US stocks have been in a long bull market, led by the Magnificent Seven. Among the Seven, three have long since seen their founders depart, with management changing generation after generation, yet their performance remains evergreen—time and the stock market have proven how formidable their business models are. Everyone knows the newbie is talking about the three MAG giants: MSFT, AAPL, GOOG. I call them the "Upper Three," clearly distinct from the "Lower Four" that still depend on their founders—the recent Nvidia incident makes this plain. Admittedly, the equity structure makes it hard to oust the founders of MAT, but no one can stop accidents, and the Lower Four have yet to prove themselves without their founders. A good business model should not depend on any individual within the company.

Let's make a ten-year bet: can the average return of the Upper Three beat VOO?

Upper Three vs VOO

Upper Three

VOO

Click to view the poll.

3
1.0K

Comments (3)

Your avatar
Sign in to comment
123123123
1231231231 week ago

In the "ten-year bet," are the returns for the Big Three and VOO calculated as price appreciation or as total return including dividends? Also, are the Big Three equally weighted or weighted by market cap? These two approaches can lead to quite different conclusions.

谷底幽兰
谷底幽兰1 week ago

Treating whether the founder is still at the helm as the core variable involves a logical leap: the fact that the latter four companies depend on their founders does not mean they would run into trouble if the founders left—it could also be that the governance structure simply never left room for outside management. Moreover, the top three have historically gone through multiple rounds of valuation compression, and which year you pick to start a ten-year window makes a huge difference to the result. If you really want to make this bet, you'd better first write down the rules for each rebalancing and the reinvestment assumptions; otherwise, ten years from now it will be very hard to judge who won.

常八九
常八九1 week ago

Is it better to invest regularly or make a lump-sum purchase?