Going to Oahu and Maui with LD over Christmas (first time in Hawaii), with 6 days and 5 nights in Maui, staying at WA. Besides lounging at the hotel, we're planning to snorkel, whale watch, and do Haleakalā volcano and the back road to Hana. Wanted to ask the knowledgeable folks here for some rental car tips. Usually for trips I either book through hertz.cn with a school or Amex CDP (can't get into the Platinum lounge, no secret codes), or National EE with a school CDP. In the past when I've rented cars, it's usually just for two or three days, mainly using Hertz + Amex, and I find having insurance included gives peace of mind. Looking at Maui rentals these days, hertz.cn is clearly more expensive than National (with CDP applied), and National isn't cheap either—$350 for 5 days without insurance. Insurance is another $50 per day.
Wanted to ask the well-informed folks here: should I rent for 5 days at OGG (and are there any other tricks to save on insurance? Credit cards seem to only cover LDW)? Or should I consider taking a taxi to the hotel and then renting a car nearby for two days during the hotel stay to concentrate on self-drive activities (which might mean switching to Avis)?
Also, for parking I'm planning to use the frugal parking spot designated by the forum, and for whale watching, can I ask the hotel concierge whether they have a package that includes pickup?
It might be clearer to break down your needs first: the volcano and the back road to Hana will basically each require a full day with a car, and snorkeling and whale watching are mostly on the other side of the island. If you stay in Waikiki, renting a car nearby for just two days may not cover these spots—better to calculate the total cost of taxis plus a short-term rental before deciding.