HuaRenCa
Back to Forum
Community

Did Morgan Stanley Amex Platinum welcome offer rules change? Can existing regular Platinum cardholders still get the SUB?

高大明
高大明

1 week ago

DP: My cousin wants to switch from the regular Amex Platinum to the Morgan Stanley Platinum, but was told during the application that he wouldn't get the welcome offer. I didn't run into this issue when I applied before.

Still, he plans to go ahead with it anyway—after all, spending $12k for 80k MR points doesn't feel quite worth it.

Did the terms change recently? I remember you could get the SUB separately for the regular Platinum and the MS Platinum, right?

7
1.1K

Comments (7)

Your avatar
Sign in to comment
阿九
阿九1 week ago

The key point: Amex treats the standard Platinum and the MS Platinum as the same product line. Once you've received the SUB on the standard version, applying for the rebranded one typically won't earn another bonus. This is separate from whether you could get both bonuses in the past—the terms haven't changed much; it's the enforcement that has tightened.

老刘用户
老刘用户1 week ago

Did your cousin get an email or a pop-up on the application page? It's best to paste the exact wording, otherwise it's easy to confuse "doesn't qualify" with "can't get it."

嘴欠王者
嘴欠王者1 week ago

I'd like to follow up: how long ago was it that he got the regular Platinum SUB? When applying for the MS version now, did he enter the same SSN? If the system immediately determined he was ineligible, does that mean Amex has already been counting these two versions together? Also, where did you see the 80k offer with 12k spend—was it a public link or targeted? These details would help others determine whether this is a general rule or a one-off case.

zhibang1983
zhibang19831 week ago

A quick heads-up: someone on the US Card Forum mentioned that the pop-up prompts may differ depending on the state or the application channel. It's best to have them screenshot and save the terms page at the time of application, to avoid any disputes later on.

豌豆豆
豌豆豆1 week ago

Spending 80k just to earn 12k isn't a great return—don't focus only on the points and overlook the opportunity cost.

齐天天
齐天天1 week ago

The key thing to pin down is whether the conclusion that he “can’t get the welcome offer” came from a system pop-up or from something a customer service rep said verbally. I’d suggest he hold off on submitting for now: go all the way to the final step of the application page to see whether an Amex pop-up appears, and at the same time dig up his SUB records for the regular Platinum card from back then so he can compare the timelines. If it’s confirmed that the offers are being counted together, he can ask customer service whether they can match him to a targeted offer, or wait until a higher offer shows up on the MS version before applying.

urolezah
urolezah1 week ago

If he's not in a hurry to use the card, he could first check whether he's been targeted for a better offer before deciding—as long as he confirms this application won't waste a hard pull for nothing.