HuaRenCa
Back to Forum
Community

It feels like it's gotten harder to publish low-quality papers in the AI era.

floy
floy

1 week ago

Recently I came up with a fun idea, and after thinking it through a bit, it seemed like it could work. I sent it to GPT to help me work out some numbers and make a few plots. But GPT went straight to some lemma buried in a dozens-of-pages-long paper from over a decade ago...

Before AI, an idea like this would probably have been enough to get a low-quality paper published. Now I figure the referee just feeds it to GPT and rejects it.

6
1.3K

Comments (6)

Your avatar
Sign in to comment
用户傲娇糖葫芦
用户傲娇糖葫芦1 week ago

If the lemma in that older paper is only close but not exactly the same setup, I'd suggest comparing the assumptions of the two line by line first, then deciding whether to work around it or cite it with an extension. The premise of this approach is that you can genuinely articulate where your contribution and novelty lie; otherwise, it's more practical to think ahead about how you'll respond to reviewers.

Dafoe
Dafoe1 week ago

Discussions like this are best when they lay out concrete scenarios and counterexamples, rather than staying at the level of lamentation.

家有少爷
家有少爷1 week ago

Look at it from another angle: stronger tools simply move the screening earlier. Things that used to slip by thanks to an information gap are now more easily flagged as duplicates, while work that genuinely adds something stands out all the more.

法官
法官1 week ago

I don't really agree with pinning the problem directly on the tools. Whether reviewers will go check older literature has always depended on the norms of the field and the journal; many ideas look like they can be churned out, but in practice you get stuck on experimental design, data availability, or the persuasiveness of the writing. AI just makes plagiarism checks and literature searches faster—you still have to figure out the boundaries yourself.

dajixiwansui
dajixiwansui1 week ago

In terms of time cost, spending extra effort upfront to review older literature may save you more trouble than submitting, getting rejected, and then revising.

老太
老太1 week ago

I want to clarify one thing: does the lemma you mentioned from over a decade ago directly overturn your core conclusion, or does it only affect some intermediate step? That determines whether we need to adjust the approach or add differentiation going forward. We also need to check whether the original paper's assumptions apply to your scenario.