What should I do when someone pulls something close to a staged accident scam?
1 week ago
Exactly two years and one day ago, in the evening while I was driving,
I saw a pedestrian crossing the street, so I stopped and waited.
That person was carrying something like a laundry bag slung diagonally, taller than their head, crossing the road, and acted as if they didn't see my car, walking straight toward it. Then the laundry bag touched my car, and the person sat down backward.
The other party asked for my phone number. I offered to call the police, but in the end this person refused and then walked away on their own. At the time, no insurance information was given.
One year later (around this time last year), this person filed a claim with their own insurance saying two cars had collided. I said that was not what happened and refused.
Today, this person again called me through their own insurance company, and this time changed the story to a car hitting a pedestrian.
But the statute of limitations for bodily injury in this state has already passed.
How should I handle this? Should I return this call? Should I report it to my own insurance company?
If you keep putting off matters like this, the other party will often keep changing their story to test you. Start by recording the time and content of each contact and the name of the other party's insurance company—you'll need it no matter which route you take later.