OP is departing from Philadelphia. UA goes to EWR, while the other two go to JFK.
London flights:
BA Club Suite - JAL 42k + 229 USD
VS Premium Economy - 815 USD
UA Premium Economy - 1077 USD
Click to view the poll.
OP is departing from Philadelphia. UA goes to EWR, while the other two go to JFK.
London flights:
BA Club Suite - JAL 42k + 229 USD
VS Premium Economy - 815 USD
UA Premium Economy - 1077 USD
Click to view the poll.
The money you save by switching flights can sometimes be eaten up by airport transfers and rechecking your bags, especially on the leg out of Philadelphia—whether it's worth it still comes down to the total travel time.
I'd suggest listing the door-to-door time for all three itineraries before comparing prices—provided you're confident about your margin for error on the transfers and connections.
The BA club suite and that tier of JAL award ticket—the breakdown of taxes and fees, whether changes or refunds are allowed, and whether the baggage allowance matches a cash ticket—aren't clearly spelled out in the main text. Please confirm so we don't run into surprises later.
The real challenge isn't the ticket price itself, but the ground transportation from Philadelphia to the two New York airports. That leg is the most easily underestimated, and the most prone to last-minute hiccups.
Looked at another way, it's more like asking whether you're willing to trade a bit more time on the ground for a lower fare or more comfort.
How much of a difference is there in time and transportation cost between going from Philadelphia to EWR versus going to JFK? If that leg isn't factored in, the airfare difference may look big, but in the end the total landed cost may not be the same thing—I'd like to hear how you weigh it.