Has AMEX lost it?? Downgraded a 7-year-old card and got an email saying I don't qualify for the welcome offer
1 week ago
What's going on.. I downgraded my Aspire to a Surpass. This Aspire has been open for 7 years and has always been an Aspire...

1 week ago
What's going on.. I downgraded my Aspire to a Surpass. This Aspire has been open for 7 years and has always been an Aspire...

Which card exactly does the email say doesn't qualify? If the system is just applying the new card's welcome offer terms, that may be a separate issue from the downgrade itself—it's best to first confirm whether the email is about a new application or a product change.
Before you rush to call and argue, keep both the downgrade confirmation email and this notice on file, then ask customer service whether this affects your existing points or benefits; if it was just a marketing email sent by mistake, going through written channels is more reliable.
A product downgrade isn't the same as opening a new account, so it actually makes sense that you wouldn't get the sign-up bonus.
Before you downgrade, do you still have any unfinished spending progress toward a card sign-up bonus in your account?