HuaRenCa
Back to Forum
Community

Catching Up with the East: NY Times Sues Brave in Federal Court, Alleging Its Ad-Blocking Paywall Bypass Violates the DMCA

单曲循還
单曲循還

1 week ago

New York Times vs. Brave could make browser paywall blockers illegal: DMCA needs reform

First, a quick primer: ad-blocking extensions are illegal in the East. Site owners suing browser companies under the Anti-Unfair Competition Law are generally upheld (1 2). This includes the splash-screen shake-to-open ads that everyone complains about and that MIIT has publicly criticized—the developer of "Li Tiaotiao," an extension that blocks shake-to-open ads, got taken down too. But I thought we lived in a free country? Not anymore, said NYT.

bypass-paywall-clean is a browser extension that has been memory-holed—even GitHub took it down, so you can only download it from Russian sites. Its functionality has two parts: a filter list and a user script. I only learned today that the filter list can also be imported into other freedom-respecting ad blockers like uBlock Origin. (Side note: using a filter list requires a browser that respects user freedom. Basically anything but Chrome: since Chrome is made by the internet's biggest advertiser, it deliberately sabotages ad blockers. Please support the DOJ's antitrust case against the great company.)

The Brave browser ships with built-in ad blocking and makes it easy to one-click enable various filter lists. One option is the bypass-paywall-clean list downloaded from Russian GitHub, which can be toggled on with one click. This list blocks three JS paths on the BS site, and then the paywall is gone.

NYT sued Brave in the Southern District of New York, alleging among other things that their browser's modification of webpage execution logic and failure to load meter.js constitutes circumvention of a Technical Protection Measure under Section 1201 of the DMCA, and also arguing that Brave should pay damages for the monetary loss caused by not displaying NYT's web ads. Of course, I also think this argument doesn't hold up, and I very much agree with Rossman's analysis, because the NYT site already shows the full text of articles for free to many users—this is a completely different matter from Netflix DRM, where without logging in you simply can't decrypt anything.

This appears to be the first US case suing a browser over ad blocking. Someone previously sued adblock plus in Europe, but that was because ABP's behavior was ugly—their model was collecting protection money from websites, a bit like extortion (don't pay the protection fee and ads get blocked; pay the protection fee and ads are allowed to display again). If NYT wins this claim and it sets a bad precedent, then all kinds of browser-side modifications could be sued by companies for civil liability in the future, and forum members won't even dare to post user scripts.

I have an obligation to implement the Streisand effect: ad-blocker users are welcome to enjoy the last of their freedom together by importing these rules to better improve the reading experience on a certain unnamed news website:

||meter-svc.nytimes.com/meter.js$xmlhttprequest,~third-party ||nytimes.com/svc/onsite-messaging/query$xmlhttprequest,~third-party ||mwcm.nyt.com/$script,domain=nytimes.com nytimes.com##div#dock-container ||cooking.nytimes.com/api/*/access$xmlhttprequest,~third-party

Or you can just import the entire bpc list—I just added it myself.

After loading correctly:

Catching Up with the East: NY Times Sues Brave in Federal Court, Alleging Its Ad-Blocking Paywall Bypass Violates the DMCA

Catching Up with the East: NY Times Sues Brave in Federal Court, Alleging Its Ad-Blocking Paywall Bypass Violates the DMCA

Catching Up with the East: NY Times Sues Brave in Federal Court, Alleging Its Ad-Blocking Paywall Bypass Violates the DMCA

Catching Up with the East: NY Times Sues Brave in Federal Court, Alleging Its Ad-Blocking Paywall Bypass Violates the DMCA

Catching Up with the East: NY Times Sues Brave in Federal Court, Alleging Its Ad-Blocking Paywall Bypass Violates the DMCA

Catching Up with the East: NY Times Sues Brave in Federal Court, Alleging Its Ad-Blocking Paywall Bypass Violates the DMCA

6
1.3K

Comments (6)

Your avatar
Sign in to comment
盘山道
盘山道1 week ago

If you're only doing this for your own personal use, check your local laws on circumventing paywalls before importing any rules—don't assume that U.S. case law means you're in the clear where you live. Also, your browser version and the rule syntax can both affect whether it works.

小猪配你
小猪配你1 week ago

You cite the fact that the NYT website displays full articles to many users for free as grounds for a DMCA defense, but paywalls inherently trigger under different conditions for different users, and courts may focus more on the circumvention method itself than on whether the full text was ultimately viewed. Moreover, Brave bundling, downloading, and enabling that list may not carry the same liability as a user manually importing rules—this point may be more critical than the technical details.

ct8929
ct89291 week ago

Even if the rules can be imported, the moment the site changes its JS paths or adds server-side validation, maintaining a filter list like this becomes a very passive, reactive job.

秦月汉关
秦月汉关1 week ago

You mentioned that after bypass-paywall-clean was taken down from GitHub, the only option is to download it from a Russian site—can you confirm that source is a mirror run by the original developer? Is there any way to verify the file hash or find the original release channel, so we can avoid getting a tampered version?

yejun1974
yejun19741 week ago

I think the most important thing to watch in this case isn't ad blocking itself, but whether the court will treat "not loading meter.js" as circumventing technical protection measures. If that holds, then any extension that modifies how a webpage executes could be swept in. But conversely, the NYT itself uses cookies and front-end scripts to control access—whether that level of protection is strong enough may be the key threshold that determines how the precedent goes.

江南许多多
江南许多多1 week ago

Before importing rules shared by someone else, it's best to verify the source—don't just enable the entire list without thinking.