HuaRenCa
Back to Forum
Community

Inflation, Market Turmoil—Can We Still Trust the 4% Rule?

二岛
二岛

1 week ago

The 4% rule is a withdrawal strategy for achieving financial independence and early retirement, introduced by scholar William Bengen in 1994. It states that if you withdraw 4% of your portfolio in your first year of retirement and adjust the withdrawal amount each subsequent year for inflation, the probability that your assets will be safely depleted within 30 years is extremely low. This figure is calculated based on the compound returns of U.S. stocks and bonds over long historical cycles, and essentially provides retirees with a "safe withdrawal rate" benchmark for sustainably drawing down assets.

However, standing at the vantage point of 2026, we face a macroeconomic environment vastly different from that of thirty years ago. After round after round of inflation fluctuations, the global interest rate hiking cycle, and the reckoning of high valuations in tech stocks, is 4% still safe enough?

7
1.4K

Comments (7)

Your avatar
Sign in to comment
邢攀
邢攀1 week ago

In practice, withdrawing 4% a year sounds fine—but when the market crashes, can you really bring yourself to do it?

我在意大利等你
我在意大利等你1 week ago

If you're planning to retire early, start by getting a clear picture of your non-investment expenses, such as health insurance and taxes—these often run higher in the years before retirement than you might expect. It's wise to keep at least two to three years' worth of withdrawals in cash or short-term bonds so you're not forced to sell assets when the market is down. But this only works if you can accept that the cash portion will lag inflation over the long run.

住在树上的鱼
住在树上的鱼1 week ago

A 30-year horizon is already long enough on its own. If it includes several consecutive years of high inflation, the 4% inflation-adjusted withdrawal amount will rise quickly, putting considerable strain on the portfolio.

随梦
随梦1 week ago

Backtests based solely on the history of U.S. stocks and Treasuries may not be representative of future asset allocations in other markets.

郦东桥
郦东桥1 week ago

Does the 4% rule still apply to non-US residents? For example, if someone is in Europe or Asia and spends mainly euros or renminbi in retirement, but their portfolio is still in US-dollar assets, would currency fluctuations erode the safe withdrawal rate? Also, since tax burdens and healthcare costs vary widely across countries, has anyone done cross-regional adjustment calculations?

青春印象
青春印象1 week ago

The core assumption of the 4% rule is that long-term stock and bond returns will outpace inflation plus withdrawals, but with valuations currently elevated, the margin of safety has indeed gotten thinner.

lanxill5555
lanxill55551 week ago

Rather than fixating on a single fixed percentage, it's better to manage extraction rates as a dynamic range.