HuaRenCa
Back to Forum
Community

Shipping from China to the US: A Rant

能奈我何
能奈我何

1 week ago

The older folks back in China heard that you can now ship things straight from home to the US by sea, so they excitedly bought a ton of stuff and toys for the kids and sent three big boxes in total. One box contained food, which counts as sensitive goods, and the other two were general cargo. Shipping came to 1,700 RMB altogether.

The two general-cargo boxes ended up being delivered by FedEx. When one of them arrived, it already had a big gash in it (see photo), with the contents spilling out. We checked right away and found that at least one item was missing—a coffee scale I'd specifically bought—plus a few small toys.

I figured this shouldn't be complicated, right? The box was obviously damaged, things were missing, so we'd just send the photos and info about the lost items to the shipping company's customer service and go through the claims process.

Little did I know, the ordeal was just beginning.

First, customer service asked: how much did the box weigh when you received it? They said they'd weighed it when shipping it out, and they needed to verify by weight.

Fine. We repacked everything into the box and weighed it: 28 lbs. The FedEx waybill said 29 lbs, which seemed about right, so we told customer service.

Then customer service said they'd weighed 40 lbs when shipping it out.

And that's when I got the feeling they were starting to suspect us...

Customer service asked for a photo of the box on a scale. The problem is, we only have a regular bathroom scale at home, and a box this big just won't sit on it steadily. Put it straight on and, because the weight is off-center, it only reads 23 lbs.

So they asked us to take more photos—showing the front of the box, the whole box visible, etc., etc. We did as asked.

Then they said photos alone weren't enough—we needed to record a video.

In the end, I had to film myself holding the box while stepping on the scale, then stepping on again empty-handed, and use the difference between the two weights to prove how much the box weighed.

After nearly an hour of back and forth, customer service finally said: don't open the box any further for now, they need to contact their overseas department to investigate, blah blah...

I was really puzzled: the box is damaged like this and things really are missing—even if there's a claim, shouldn't that be between the logistics company and the insurer? Why does it feel like we're the ones proving our innocence, as if they're afraid we're scamming them?

I vented to my LD (better half), and LD said maybe they never bought insurance in the first place, and maybe they really do think we took the stuff ourselves and then falsely claimed it was lost.

I said, but our stuff really is missing!

LD shot back: then how do you prove it?

And I honestly couldn't answer.

Because the older folks bought everything back in China and dropped it off together at the shipping company, which handled the packing, weighing, and shipping. We have neither a complete packing video nor a list and weight for each item. Now the box is damaged and we really did find things missing, but strictly proving exactly what's missing is genuinely impossible.

What's even worse is that the other box—the sensitive one—didn't go smoothly either. It got held up by UPS, something about fraud. LD spent all day on the phone and still hasn't figured out what's going on, let alone how to fix it.

At the end of the day, the lost items aren't worth much. What really stings is the whole process.

The older folks meant well, wanting to send the kids things they'd like—spending money, putting in effort, finally getting it across the ocean. And then one box arrives damaged with things missing, another gets held up, and when problems come up we have to repeatedly take photos, weigh things, and record videos, until it feels like we're the ones under suspicion.

I get that logistics companies need to verify things and guard against fraudulent claims. But normal claims verification and making customers feel like they're being treated as scammers from the get-go are two different things, aren't they?

Or is it that in the domestic transaction environment in China, the cost of trust between people is just too high?

Shipping from China to the US: A Rant

Shipping from China to the US: A Rant

5
236

Comments (5)

Your avatar
Sign in to comment
Vance
Vance1 week ago

Quick question—when you receive FedEx packages on your end, does the courier ask you to open the box and inspect it in person before signing? Over here, it seems the default is just drop it and go, and they only take photos if there's obvious damage. If FedEx practices vary this much from place to place, that leaves a lot of room for disputes later on. Regarding the weight discrepancy you mentioned—could it be that the scale the shipping company uses is different from FedEx's?

腾西天讯芭比球
腾西天讯芭比球1 week ago

Honestly, spending this much time and effort over a few lost items doesn't seem worth it to me. We already paid 1,700 in shipping, and the claims process is such a hassle—once you factor in the time cost, it probably costs more than the items themselves. I'd rather sort out the UPS box first and just chalk up the general cargo box as a lesson learned.

18010473116
180104731161 week ago

If you plan to keep pursuing this, first ask them in writing to provide photos of the weight at the time of packing and the packing records, and see whether they can produce them. But only if you're willing to keep dragging this out.

lyn521
lyn5211 week ago

I noticed one detail: you said the elderly person bought the items and sent them together to the shipping company, which packed and weighed them. So who exactly provides the packing list? If the shipping company only charges by total weight and doesn't record each individual item, then if something goes missing, there's no way to check item by item. When customer service asks you to prove the box weight, it's actually because they don't have their own unpacking records either. If this point isn't clarified, you could end up in disputes no matter which company you switch to.

klkl
klkl1 week ago

The core issue isn't whether trust is costly—it's that there's no documentation of the packing and inspection steps in cross-border logistics. The elderly person meant well, but the sender had no checklist and the recipient took no unboxing video, so when something goes wrong, the only way to prove anything is by weighing the package. To make this discussion more useful, it would help to talk about how to leave evidence cheaply before shipping—for example, having the person who packs the order record a video of each item being packed.