HuaRenCa
Back to Forum
Community

Will Amex shut down all my accounts?

巴交
巴交

1 week ago

I've held the P1 Platinum for about 5 years. Later, since I got the P2 Platinum card, using many of the benefits became a hassle, so I was thinking of downgrading to the Green card. The issue is that my renewal date is at the end of December, which is just in time to use the $300 hotel credit for the first half of next year in early January. I'd like to ask: if I wait until I get the credit and then immediately downgrade to the Green card, is there a chance Amex will shut down all my accounts? Actually, I could just close the card—I have a checking account that keeps my miles—but I'd still like to maintain a good relationship with Amex. Thanks for any advice.

Will Amex shut down all my accounts?

7
430

Comments (7)

Your avatar
Sign in to comment
FT13718552
FT137185521 week ago

Before downgrading, it's worth confirming one thing first: whether the hotel credit you've received will be clawed back proportionally after the downgrade, or whether the $300 for this half-year is prorated based on how long you've held the card. A lot of people focus only on "grab it first, then downgrade" and overlook Amex's clawback mechanism for credits—especially when you change products right after receiving the credit, the odds of getting flagged by the system are higher than if you'd used the card for a normal year before downgrading.

quexin
quexin1 week ago

For these six months, is the credit given on a pro-rata basis or in full?

雫尤
雫尤1 week ago

It's worth double-checking whether the renewal day you mentioned and the credit cycle are calculated the same way. If the two timing points don't line up, downgrading right after receiving the credit will look more abrupt to the system, so it would be best to share the billing cycle as well so we can take a look.

Barnaby
Barnaby1 week ago

The key thing to watch is the timing of "downgrading right after you get the bonus." Even if you've decided to downgrade, don't do it on the same day the credit posts—wait one billing cycle, use the benefits you're entitled to as normal, and then downgrade. It'll look much more natural that way. Also, think carefully about whether the Green Card is really right for you—don't keep switching products just to save on the annual fee.

nana1987307
nana19873071 week ago

If P2 also has Platinum, first check whether the two people's benefits overlap after downgrading to Green.

肉乎蛋
肉乎蛋1 week ago

On the rules alone, taking the credit and then downgrading doesn't necessarily trigger a review, but doing it right after you get the credit can easily look like arbitrage. What really determines the risk is your overall account usage pattern, not this one action, so don't focus on this single move.

wow
wow1 week ago

I actually think the key question isn't necessarily whether you'll get shut down, but whether the relationship is still worth maintaining after you downgrade to the Green card. The Green card's benefits are quite different from the Platinum's. If you're only trying to preserve your miles, a checking account is already enough—you don't necessarily have to go the downgrade route. You could first compare which is less hassle: downgrading or closing the card.