Just a casual post. I'm male, and my LD (wife) is female. LD recently made the following hot take, and I'd like to discuss it with the forum folks. LD says brokerages should launch a VOO gift card service: pay a small fee and have the brokerage make a beautifully designed VOO gift card. The recipient can deposit the giver's VOO into their own account (preserving the cost basis), and there's also a nice physical card to ensure a sense of ceremony. The reasoning is that many jewelry gifts tend to depreciate, giving cash directly feels too casual, whereas VOO can appreciate in value—and if you don't like VOO, they could also offer gift cards for different stocks/ETFs.
Comments (6)
I think keeping the cost basis is a real hassle—transfers between brokers are already prone to problems.
You mentioned that if you don't like VOO, you can switch to other stocks or ETF gift cards. How does the brokerage handle gift cards with no specified underlying security? Is the security locked in at issuance, or does the recipient choose it themselves? Also, preserving cost basis requires both brokerages to support a specific transfer method—is there a specific industry rule or precedent to reference for this, or is it currently just a concept?
Looking at it from another angle, this is more about solving the ceremonial aspect of gift-giving than about innovating the investment tool itself. In reality, many gift cards end up unused or resold at a discount, and if the recipient of a stock gift card doesn't know how to use it, it just adds hassle.
The real challenge lies in compliance and tax integration, not in how good the card design looks.
If you simply want to balance a sense of ceremony with preserving value, consider running a small-scale pilot first—for example, with a brokerage's internal employees or a specific customer group. The prerequisite is clearly defining who is responsible for tax reporting on gift cards, any transfer restrictions, and the rules for handling unclaimed cards; otherwise, it is easy to leave room for disputes.
In the U.S., there may also be gift tax filing thresholds to consider—the rules differ for the giver and the recipient, and cross-state or cross-border situations vary even more. The scenarios discussed in the post should first take these regional differences into account.