HuaRenCa
Back to Forum
Community

YYZ-SIN: Whole family in economy (*4) or leave LD behind and take two kids in business?

岁岁平安
岁岁平安

2 weeks ago

Planning to go to Singapore next year. LD has a business trip, so economy tickets will be reimbursed. Originally I used UA 55k/each to redeem 3 economy tickets YYZ-HND-SIN for me and the 2 kids, and LD also bought the same flight with cash (about $1,000 or so, which meets the reimbursement requirement and conveniently also triggered the Platinum card's $200 back offer). The overall itinerary isn't too much of a hassle. Not saying the miles redemption is a great deal, but at least it's not too outrageous.

But a while back I caught Air China opening up business-class award availability, so I quickly booked 3 tickets YYZ-BEK-SIN (the day after the original tickets), with Air China business for the first leg (albeit the old CA994) and Singapore Airlines economy for the second leg. Didn't get to be happy for long before discovering that the corresponding economy tickets actually cost over $1,800 (LD may have trouble getting that reimbursed)... Now I'm a bit torn about whether to give up business and switch back to the original tickets, for the following reasons:

  1. LD says she doesn't care about business vs. economy. I originally planned to honestly go sit in economy in the back and let her take the two kids in business. She said "in your dreams"—she'd rather go sit quietly in the back in cattle class by herself, even if it means being on a different flight. I don't think taking two kids (2 and 7) in business would be that hard, but I'm a bit unsure whether LD is saying one thing and meaning another.

  2. Not sure whether the old CA994 is worth paying an extra $1,800 for same-flight economy tickets, or even having the wife fly on a different flight. Wondering if there's a way to refund the tickets already bought first and then get them reimbursed, and then figure out how to issue an award ticket?

Not a big deal, but it's rare to snag 3 business award seats, so I'm a bit reluctant to give them up. Would like to hear everyone's suggestions, thanks!

Keep the business tickets, figure out a way to get myself a cattle-class ticket on the same itinerary

Take the kids in business myself, get LD a cash cattle-class ticket on another flight the same day (help)

CA994 business is garbage, whole family flies cattle class together

Click to view the poll.

YYZ-SIN: Whole family in economy (*4) or leave LD behind and take two kids in business?

7
984

Comments (7)

Your avatar
Sign in to comment
电瓶批发
电瓶批发2 weeks ago

Before you rush to calculate whether the mileage is worth it, there may be a prerequisite on the reimbursement side that hasn't been confirmed: whether the company has caps on cabin class and fare, whether you can book non-same-flight itineraries, and whether finance will block reimbursement after a refund. If these aren't clear, any choice you make later could be wasted effort—I suggest you first get the reimbursement policy nailed down.

真的好珍惜
真的好珍惜2 weeks ago

The key takeaway: don't split the family across different flights just to save on three business-class tickets. Traveling with two young kids comes with too many variables, and the comfort you gain is rarely worth the coordination hassle and the risk.

爱丽思
爱丽思1 week ago

Let's first assume that LD isn't just being polite, and seriously plan it out according to what she wants.

雅艺画框油画
雅艺画框油画1 week ago

When you mention that LD said she'd rather sit quietly in economy on her own, even on a different flight, that's not something to just laugh off. With a two-year-old and a seven-year-old on a long trip, what really wears you down usually isn't the width of the seat—it's the feeding, the bathroom runs, the getting them to sleep. If she'd rather fly alone, she may be telling you she needs a break, not just being polite.

菩提香珊
菩提香珊1 week ago

I wouldn't be so quick to assume that flying business class with a kid is a breeze, and I don't think old CA business class is worth paying an extra 1,800 for. You'd be better off comparing the refund loss against the cash fare before deciding.

改涨薪了
改涨薪了1 week ago

If I get a refund and then submit it for reimbursement, will Finance accept it?

rubailee
rubailee1 week ago

If we end up leaning toward keeping the business-class ticket, how do you plan to handle the seat for ld on that flight: buy her a separate cash economy ticket for that day, or keep looking for an award ticket? Also, could you spell out the seating arrangements for the two kids and who will be with whom during the layover? That way everyone can better judge whether splitting the flights is actually feasible.