HuaRenCa
Back to Forum
Community

In the US, does a no-fault sideswipe always mean a loss?

nancy520
nancy520

2 weeks ago

Hey everyone

Today I was stuck in traffic in a queue, and someone insisted on cutting in, forcing their way in.

I remember reading a lawyer's popular-science explanation that in the US, the car going straight is also not at fault.

I figure that as long as I don't yield, our two cars will scrape together.

The other person's car is an Infiniti, not too beat up, so I feel like they probably have insurance.

My front-left already had damage, so if it got hit, I could get it fixed along the way.

It's just that I don't know whether, when everything is tallied up in the end, it would still be a loss.

So in the end I didn't crash, and I don't know if I missed out on a destined encounter?

4
1.7K

Comments (4)

Your avatar
Sign in to comment
Lq991222
Lq9912222 weeks ago

You mentioned that "a car going straight has no liability"—how exactly is that defined in California? For example, if the other driver forces their way into your lane but uses their turn signal, or if your front bumper has already made contact, would the liability determination be different? Also, your front-left area already had prior damage—how does the insurance company distinguish new damage from old damage when handling a claim? If these two points aren't clarified, it's hard to reach any conclusion about whether it's worth pursuing. Have you found any more specific cases or clauses?

zwxzwx
zwxzwx2 weeks ago

Even if the other party is fully at fault, what do you do about not having a car while yours is in the shop for insurance repairs? The other side's insurer may not readily agree to cover a rental car, and pre-existing damage could affect the claims assessment—you also have to factor in these time costs.

荒树
荒树1 week ago

Laws vary considerably from state to state, so you can't just treat every case as no-fault.

Grace1668
Grace16681 week ago

Look at it from a different angle: instead of agonizing over whether you'll get hit, first make sure your dashcam is set up and check your insurance policy for subrogation and rental reimbursement clauses. If someone really forces their way in, keeping video evidence is more worthwhile than arguing at the scene. You can also find a local traffic accident lawyer for a free consultation and ask exactly how pre-existing injuries factor into damage assessments—once you know where you stand, you'll know next time whether to yield or not.