HuaRenCa
Back to Forum
Community

Review: Xiaomi S800 Body Fat Scale

hardy2
hardy2

2 weeks ago

I'd been using a regular body fat scale that only measures resistance through the feet, and it put my body fat at just over ten percent, which didn't seem right. Recently I had a Xiaomi S800 body fat scale shipped over from China, and it reads about 5% higher than my old scale—closer to the numbers I got from an InBody scan at a physical, and it can measure muscle and fat in different parts of the body, with numbers very close to InBody's.

According to Xiaomi, it has a DEXA correlation of 0.97, and if it's really that accurate, that's pretty impressive. Once I have time, I'm planning to get a DEXA scan at BodySpec to compare—if the numbers match, I won't need to spend $60 every time.

If you have a Xiaomi Bluetooth gateway at home, you don't need to open your phone for each measurement—the data is sent to the gateway automatically, which is very convenient.

But if you don't have a Bluetooth gateway at home, I'd recommend buying another 8-electrode body fat scale with WiFi instead of one that only has regular Bluetooth, since personally I think not having to pull out your phone for every measurement is a must.

I bought it in China for only 200 USD, though shipping was almost another 200. Still cheaper than a single DEXA scan.

4
825

Comments (4)

Your avatar
Sign in to comment
Ilias
Ilias2 weeks ago

You mentioned that Xiaomi claims a DEXA correlation of 0.97. That figure is more of a population-level statistical result derived from algorithmic fitting, and the error for any single individual could be considerable. Eight electrodes do indeed capture much more information than measuring only the feet, but electrode placement on the hands and feet, standing posture, and skin moisture can all affect the readings. I'd suggest measuring at the same time of day and on an empty stomach; otherwise, comparisons between readings won't mean much.

chenfo330
chenfo3302 weeks ago

Without a Bluetooth gateway, this scale's convenience is actually compromised. Before buying, you need to confirm whether you have a Xiaomi device at home that can serve as a gateway—otherwise, pulling out your phone every time is indeed a hassle.

liya
liya2 weeks ago

Don't rush to use it as a complete replacement for DEXA—wait until you've compared them yourself.

核桃露子
核桃露子2 weeks ago

When you plan to do a comparison at BodySpec, how exactly are you going to control the variables? For example, how long will you wait between the two measurements, will they be on the same day, and how will you arrange your food and exercise the night before? Also, InBody itself fluctuates across different locations and different electrode contact conditions, so if Xiaomi comes close to one particular InBody reading, that doesn't necessarily mean it's accurate—it might just be that the InBody happened to be in a similar state that time. I'd like to hear what criteria you plan to use to judge whether they're consistent or not.