Hot Take: When Your Asset-to-Income Ratio Exceeds 15–20, Giving Up Your Green Card Is the Economically Optimal Choice
2 weeks ago
Hot Take: When Your Asset-to-Income Ratio Exceeds 15 or 20, Giving Up Your Green Card Is the Economically Optimal Choice
For the detailed math, see my earlier post; here I'll just add a fudge factor of 15–20x.
A few major reasons:
-
Expected growth in labor income is usually low. Once taxes significantly erode your labor income, it's highly likely you won't be able to reverse course, and the erosion will only get worse.
-
For people who build assets mainly through their own labor income, once their asset-to-income ratio hits 15 or 20, their career has typically already moved from a high-growth phase into a stable one. Unless they were chronically underpaid for years, it's usually hard to achieve a several-fold salary increase through a promotion or job change—meaning it's unlikely they can proactively improve the situation in point 1 through their own efforts.
-
For people who build assets mainly not through their own labor income (e.g., primarily through family gifts), they don't need the job opportunities a green card provides. Families like this usually aren't choosing to have their children apply for a green card primarily for economic reasons, so whether it's economically optimal doesn't really matter.
-
Common tax-avoidance strategies have limited effectiveness and scope. For example, going all in on VOO won't stop it from paying dividends. The so-called buy-borrow-die strategy not only fails to stop dividends but also has questionable long-term stability—it's hard to guarantee that ordinary users won't be forced to sell stocks at market lows to repay debt during the next economic crisis. Food for thought: In the perfect storm that sank giants like Bear Stearns, Lehman, and Merrill Lynch, would a brokerage holding a "call the loan anytime" clause really stand by its borrowers and hold out, or would it rush to raise more cash to try to save itself?
Finally, a blunt simulation scenario:
Take just 2% in dividends, pay 10% to the IRS, and you still net 50% to 70%+ of the after-tax disposable portion of labor income—all without grinding away or slacking off all year.
Corollary: If you're going to end up on the path of building assets through your own labor income and then giving up your green card, why did you chase it so hard in the first place? Why not just not apply from the start and save yourself XX years of detours?

Your premise that 'giving up the green card is the optimal solution' assumes a stable asset-to-income ratio with no major fluctuations ahead, but in reality both asset prices and income can change dramatically—if you lose your job or the market crashes, the denominator drops sharply and the ratio spikes instantly, potentially leaving you stuck in an impossible position. So shouldn't this threshold be viewed dynamically rather than as a one-size-fits-all cutoff?