Can I get Hong Kong permanent residency with dual Chinese-Canadian citizenship?
2 weeks ago
It is known that, from start to finish, holding only a Canadian passport plus having China as the place of birth allows one to obtain Chinese-national Hong Kong permanent residency (HKSAR passport + Home Return Permit) in 7 years. No need to elaborate on this; there are data points online and among people around me.
So can the following two plans obtain Chinese-national Hong Kong permanent residency?
Plan 1: At the time of first applying for the HK visa and entering HK, hold only a Chinese passport + Canadian PR. During the seven years, obtain Canadian citizenship and a Canadian passport, then "change travel document" on the HK visa application to transfer it to the Canadian passport, give up the mainland Chinese passport and apply for a Q1/Q2 visa, never apply for a "change of nationality" in Hong Kong, and continue to reside for the full seven years.
Plan 2: At the time of first applying for the HK visa and entering HK, hold only a Chinese passport + Canadian PR. During the seven years, obtain Canadian citizenship and a Canadian passport, but do not give up the mainland Chinese passport, do not apply for a Chinese visa, keep the Hong Kong visa always on the mainland Chinese document, and use the Canadian passport only when flying from Hong Kong to other regions, never presenting it in mainland China. After residing for the full seven years, when verifying permanent residency, if the officer asks whether you hold another country's passport, truthfully state that you have a Canadian passport.
It is known that someone is already proceeding with Plan 1 and has asked the Immigration Department, which said it is feasible, but because permanent residency has not yet been verified, it cannot be fully confirmed.
Plan 2's main concern is whether the Hong Kong side will "punish" someone for "dual holding," thereby preventing them from obtaining Chinese-national Hong Kong permanent residency.
Note that neither of the above plans is about obtaining a One-way Permit; they only use ordinary visas such as a student visa + IANG / QMAS / TTPS / dependant visa to accumulate the full seven years.
Looking forward to the insights of the experts on this forum!
Regarding Option 1, I think the part about giving up the "pork liver red" passport after "changing travel documents" deserves more thought. Just because Immigration says it's feasible doesn't necessarily mean they won't probe, during the seven-year verification, into how your status connects before and after the change of nationality. It's best to keep a complete record of the document each visa was tied to.