Paris Grand Hotel du Palais Royal, an SLH Hotel Experience + Compensation Advice Needed
2 weeks ago
On this trip to Paris, I booked 3 nights at the Grand Hotel du Palais Royal using Hilton FN. First, the pros: the location is genuinely excellent—you walk out the door and you're at the Louvre, and walking to the Musée d'Orsay/Musée de l'Orangerie is also doable. However, we also ran into quite a few problems:
Starting from the second day, the key card had to be reactivated at the front desk every day
The card reader on the door fell off entirely on the second day
There were USB ports in the room, but none of them had power
The elevator was broken for 2 days
The most ridiculous part: at checkout they said there was no balance at all, and the deposit given via UA was returned immediately. Turns out they quietly charged 75 euros to my other Amex Business Platinum card. Fortunately, I hadn't used this quarter's Hilton credit yet—I only found out when I received an Amex email congratulating me on earning the Hilton credit. I emailed to ask, and they said it was for Champagne from the minibar. As a non-drinking points chaser, I know minibar items cost money and I didn't touch it at all... I immediately had ChatGPT write an email asking them to look into it properly. The latest reply is that they made a mistake and will issue a refund..
In this situation, I should be able to ask for points compensation, right? Although we booked with FN, if it were points, one night should be 120k–150k. Any experienced friends who can advise on how much is appropriate to ask for?
Beyond compensation, I'd suggest putting together a timeline of the details—the key card not working, the card reader falling off, the USB having no power, and the elevator being out for two days—and sending it to the hotel and Hilton customer service for the record. First, clearly ask them to confirm in writing that the erroneous charge has been reversed, and then discuss point compensation. That way, you'll have a stronger basis.