I recently had to go back to China for something, and I managed to redeem F awards from JL Miles and AC for JFK-HND and NRT-ORD, one week apart. Here are some fresh impressions for everyone.
JAL was 35K. The hard product was beyond reproach, and even though the flight originated in the US, the food was still excellent.
The caviar with the little snacks she brought was very tasty.
This soupy rice dish was delicious—fish with broth, great seasoning, top-tier freshness.
The beef main course wasn't good; I don't know why it was on the sour side, but it just wasn't to my taste. The chestnut rice was good.
The other dishes were decent but unremarkable.
The coffee came with a cinnamon stick, which was a slightly classy touch.
On the way back, the food in ANA's Suite Lounge was pretty mediocre, and I'd already expected the onboard food might be average too. For a direct comparison, I still chose the Japanese meal.
What they paired with the caviar was a bit incongruous and didn't taste good.
This beef soup was pretty good.
ANA does have its strong points: their pajamas are more comfortable to wear, and I took them home—slept well in them too. Also, one of the ANA flight attendants bore a slight resemblance to Miyazawa Rie—call it a service premium, but there's nothing to complain about. Conclusion: next time on ANA, I'll just stick with the Western menu.








There's actually a precondition when it comes to choosing meals: how Japanese cuisine performs on a plane depends heavily on the departure point and the catering kitchen. The same airline departing from Japan versus from the US may have completely different caviar pairings and rice quality. So simply comparing one JL flight departing from JFK with one ANA flight departing from Narita may not necessarily reflect the overall standard of the two airlines' Japanese cuisine.