HuaRenCa
Back to Forum
Community

NRT to Osaka Station: Train or Plane?

后仰哥
后仰哥

2 weeks ago

Hey everyone, quick question: from NRT to Osaka Station (WA Osaka), which is more convenient?

N'EX to Shinagawa → Shinkansen to Shin-Osaka → taxi to WA Osaka

Fly NRT to ITM → taxi to WA Osaka

At first I thought about just flying, but I've seen people's DPs saying the plane isn't even better than the Shinkansen—might actually take longer.

Departing SEA, arriving NRT around 4pm. Two adults, two checked bags. Not considering the bus—last time I got off the plane and took the limo bus directly and felt really carsick.

If there's a better route from SEA to KIX/ITM than SEA→NRT, please recommend that too.

NRT to Osaka Station: Train or Plane?

6
688

Comments (6)

Your avatar
Sign in to comment
ccccc-
ccccc-2 weeks ago

Four adults with two large suitcases—factor in immigration and baggage claim time first. Landing at NRT at 4 p.m., you might not clear customs and get your bags until after 5, and then catching the Shinkansen to Osaka Station could get late. If the flight is on time and you don't mind arriving late, the train option is more predictable.

ThunderBolt
ThunderBolt2 weeks ago

Transferring to the Shinkansen with two checked bags means you'll need to think about the transfer at Shinagawa and luggage space on the train—large suitcases sometimes require a reservation or finding a spot. Add a taxi from Shin-Osaka to the hotel, and splitting the fare four ways is reasonable, but the total cost has to include all three legs—NEX, Shinkansen, and taxi—so it may not end up much cheaper than a flight.

善慈
善慈2 weeks ago

ITM isn't actually that close to Osaka Station—don't underestimate the taxi distance.

ls199411
ls1994112 weeks ago

The key is whether you can catch the last suitable Shinkansen of the day after clearing immigration, and whether there's a direct, reasonably routed flight from NRT to ITM. With four adults traveling with luggage, the number of connections and how far the arrival airport is from the hotel often matter more to the experience than flight time; people departing from different origins will have very different impressions.

卓业兴
卓业兴2 weeks ago

When you say the flight takes longer in the DP, do you mean the total time from getting off the plane to arriving at the hotel, or just the flight plus layover? Also, for the 4pm departure from SEA arriving at NRT, is that the same day or the next day, and how much time is there for the domestic connection? I can only judge once these details are confirmed.

dvs
dvs2 weeks ago

With two large suitcases and four people, the number of transfers should be kept to a minimum.