HuaRenCa
Back to Forum
Community

Should I book ANA round-trip SFO-TYO J with AC or ANA miles?

amar
amar

2 weeks ago

Recently transferred MR to AC and booked two round-trip ANA business class tickets SFO-HND/NRT (355 days out)

AC charges 100k points per person one-way flexible

But after ticketing, I'm wondering whether it would be cheaper to transfer points earlier and book with ANA miles in the future (50–82.5k)

Are there any downsides?

5
775

Comments (5)

Your avatar
Sign in to comment
阿成
阿成2 weeks ago

I think you can look at this question the other way around: rather than comparing whether AC or ANA is cheaper, it's about whether you value flexibility in miles or redemption cost more. Although AC requires 100k, MR transfers often come with bonuses, so the actual cost may not be that high; although ANA only requires 50–82.5k, transfer channels are limited, and its change and cancellation rules are stricter. If your itinerary is fixed and you can lock in ANA miles in advance, then it really is a good deal; otherwise, AC's flexibility is worth the price difference.

这个杀手手不稳
这个杀手手不稳2 weeks ago

Just a heads-up: while ANA's own mileage redemptions may look cheap, they might not release any seats to their own members during peak season or close to departure—especially in business class. Booking 355 days out is already very early. If you're planning to switch to ANA miles, it's best to confirm first whether saver award seats are available at that time, so you don't transfer your points only to find there are no seats available.

岚江
岚江2 weeks ago

There's also a hidden cost: ANA miles expire after three years, while AC miles don't expire but incur a loss when transferring points.

chj1122
chj11222 weeks ago

You mentioned that AC is 100k one-way flexible per person—what exactly does "flexible" refer to here? Is it AC's flexible redemption policy or ANA's? If it's AC's flexible option, the change and cancellation rules may be much more lenient than ANA's, and that value shouldn't be judged on points alone. Also, after ticketing at 355 days out, have you checked ANA's award inventory for the same flight on the same day? If ANA simply isn't releasing seats, then the cheaper price is only theoretical.

杨尚
杨尚2 weeks ago

I'd suggest holding off on transferring points just yet. Use ANA's calendar to check the saver award availability for SFO-TYO business class over the next year, and see whether the time frames you usually fly have consistent availability. If awards only open up on scattered dates, it's safer to stick with AC; if you can redeem on most dates, then consider transferring miles to ANA in advance. The catch is that you'd need to be okay with ANA miles expiring after three years and the change restrictions.