HuaRenCa
Back to Forum
Community

Tan You Didn't Grasp the Difference Between Two Kinds of Freedom

蔡东南
蔡东南

2 weeks ago

Free from what? What does Zarathustra care! But your eye should tell me brightly: free for what?

Breaking free from constraints does not automatically give life meaning.

You quit your job, no longer have to listen to your boss, no longer have to work for money—these are all freedom in the negative sense.

But what exactly do you want to create? What kind of person do you want to become? How do you want to arrange your life?

This is freedom in the positive sense.

True freedom means being able to live according to the values you yourself endorse, and even being willing to take on hard work, solitude, and risk for the sake of your own creation.

So freedom and effort are not in conflict.

A person who works twelve hours a day may still be free, because this is a creation of his own choosing.

Another person, even if financially free and idle every day, may still be dominated by emptiness, others' judgments, or desire.

Finally, here is my favorite poem.

Tell me, what else should I have done? Doesn't everything die at last, and too soon? Tell me, what is it you plan to do with your one wild and precious life?

@打豆豆

5
21

Comments (5)

Your avatar
Sign in to comment
凡提
凡提2 weeks ago

If you treat "positive freedom" as meaning you must immediately find your life's mission after quitting your job, you may just end up putting more pressure on yourself. My advice is to first set aside a few months for trial and error—provided you can afford it financially—and only then talk about creating.

uscredit101
uscredit1012 weeks ago

Just curious: what you said about "working twelve hours a day and still being free" varies quite a bit across industries. For example, people with family responsibilities or whose visas are tied to their jobs may have a completely different set of options—should we discuss that part separately?

tyyu333
tyyu3332 weeks ago

You can start by noting down the things you're genuinely willing to invest time in—there's no need to rush into defining "creation."

魔法热狗
魔法热狗2 weeks ago

I think the key difference isn't whether you're busy or not, but whether the choice is your own. Some people have all the time in the world yet constantly worry about others' opinions, while others are exhausted but at peace with it—those really are two different things.

西岭泉
西岭泉2 weeks ago

One caveat: tying freedom too tightly to hard work can overlook the cost in time. Even if it's voluntary, twelve-hour days over the long run can crowd out health, relationships, and room for reflection—and a sense of meaning can't necessarily offset all of those costs.