HuaRenCa
Back to Forum
Community

Stock Market Bloodbath: Beware of Wash Sales—Almost Took a Tumble

jayant
jayant

2 weeks ago

I got badly burned trying to bottom-fish semiconductors, and my plan was to sell at a loss to offset gains if I couldn't turn it around. But when prices were low, I couldn't resist buying a little in my Roth IRA. I'd never mixed buying and selling between a regular account and a retirement account before, so I specifically looked into wash sales. I found that if the Roth is involved and you buy the same security within 30 days, the loss from the regular account's sale disappears forever. Just a heads-up for everyone.

I haven't sold yet. There's still time to fix it. I just need to sell the shares bought in the Roth account more than 30 days later, which should satisfy the requirement of not being within 30 days before or after the loss sale. I'll tough it out until next month.

7
41

Comments (7)

Your avatar
Sign in to comment
Yiming0000
Yiming00002 weeks ago

Before selling next month, confirm the trade date and settlement date—don't overlook any holidays.

beautybracedent
beautybracedent2 weeks ago

The key point is that losses in a regular account can be wiped out by purchases made in a retirement account—this mechanism isn't very intuitive, and in practice the biggest risk is losing track of which purchase you made on which day.

transport
transport2 weeks ago

Look at it from a different angle: the real issue isn't whether the loss disappears forever, but that the cost basis gets shifted to the purchase made inside the retirement account. You lose the tax benefit in the taxable account, but the money doesn't vanish into thin air economically—it's just being accounted for in a different place.

邓洪妹
邓洪妹2 weeks ago

I think we shouldn't jump to conclusions just yet—it'd be best to double-check how the specific brokerage handles this.

豆腐渣
豆腐渣2 weeks ago

If Rose's account added to that buy position afterward, is the 30-day window counted from the first transaction or the last one—have you clarified that boundary?

吻过地平线
吻过地平线2 weeks ago

What's most noteworthy is actually the phrase "the loss disappears forever." Strictly speaking, it doesn't disappear—it just can't be used to offset taxes, because the cost basis is transferred to the replacement shares you buy, and only shows up when you sell later. So what you really need to figure out is: if you delay the sale until next month, could the loss from stock price fluctuations be greater than the tax you save?

J姐
J姐2 weeks ago

If a bonus or other income comes in at the end of the year, you might be tempted to buy a bit more—just think it through before you act.