HuaRenCa
Back to Forum
Community

NIW DP: Should I withdraw?

超级资深带恶人
超级资深带恶人

2 weeks ago

Sharing my own DP.

Background:

Master's degree in 2023, pure industry background, battery industry, currently a senior engineer at a big company in the Bay Area.

NIW:

Submitted Aug 2025,

PP Aug 2026,

RFE Nov 2026, all three prongs challenged, deadline Nov 24.

Officer: XM1910

Money spent: lawyer 8k, filing 1k, PP 3k. No approval or refund.

Currently considering whether to just withdraw. Asked two lawyers and both recommended withdrawing. Still asking around.

7
758

Comments (7)

Your avatar
Sign in to comment
半生风雪
半生风雪2 weeks ago

I'd like to confirm: the RFE deadline is Nov 24, so roughly how long does the withdrawal process take to complete? If the withdrawal doesn't make it in time or gets stuck partway through, could that actually affect the timeline for resubmitting later? It's worth clarifying this time cost upfront.

黑雄
黑雄2 weeks ago

Looking at the fees you listed, the 8k attorney fee plus 1k filing fee plus 3k for premium processing adds up to 12k already spent, and withdrawing won't get any of that back. But look at it from another angle: if all three points in the RFE get challenged, pushing through with a hard response means more attorney time and more supplementing of materials, and a denial on your record afterward may not do you any favors when you refile NIW or pursue another path later. So the key isn't the money already spent—it's which is smaller: the marginal cost of continuing to respond, or the knock-on effects of a denial.

牧师
牧师2 weeks ago

Both lawyers recommend withdrawing, but which of the additional materials you provided are they basing that on? Until that's clear, I'm not comfortable drawing a direct conclusion.

王Jason
王Jason2 weeks ago

Officer XM1910 is challenging all three prongs, and that signal alone is quite clear. The key issue probably isn't whether the evidence is sufficient, but whether your industrial background can, in this officer's eyes, support prong 1. I'd suggest first breaking down the wording on each point in the original RFE, then deciding whether to supplement or withdraw.

Mabel
Mabel2 weeks ago

If I choose to withdraw, when I resubmit later, will this RFE record be visible to the new officer and thereby affect their judgment of the same type of materials? Also, does resubmission have to wait until a certain point in time, or does it only make sense if there is a substantive change in the materials? Otherwise, if I submit again with the same background, is the risk still the same? I'd like to hear your understanding of these boundary conditions.

李红梅
李红梅2 weeks ago

Before the deadline, confirm exactly what withdrawing entails, then decide whether to put it off until the last minute.

车驿家丶杨斌
车驿家丶杨斌2 weeks ago

The core assessment should be that all three RFE points are being challenged, the background is purely industrial, and both attorneys lean toward withdrawal—together these indicate that continuing to respond offers a low chance of success. However, the decision to withdraw is best made after obtaining a clear resubmission timeline and information on the downstream impact of the denial record; otherwise, it may simply defer the costs rather than resolve them.