Recently I had a meal at a restaurant attached to a Holiday Inn and charged it to my room, then went into the IHG app and redeemed the credit, all normal.
At check-out I forgot to ask for the final bill, and only today did I discover that the $25 was actually never deducted.
I emailed the front desk, and the reply was: the credit must be requested and applied during your stay, prior to check-out.
Is there any way to fight this? If I'd known, I should have taken a screenshot when I redeemed the credit.
If the app really shows it as redeemed, I'd suggest not relying solely on back-and-forth emails with the front desk. You can ask them to check the deduction record on the room folio from that time, and send them your redemption page in the app along with your check-in details. This assumes you did complete the redemption before check-out—otherwise the hotel can reasonably decline it under their terms. Feel free to update if you get a conclusion later.