HuaRenCa
Back to Forum
Community

How did Lo Ta-yu become a U.S. citizen after living in the U.S. for only 25 months?

太可怕了去
太可怕了去

2 days ago

Here is the known timeline for Lo Ta-yu:

Time Fact Source

July 20, 1954 Born in Taipei Biography

December 31, 1984 Held a farewell concert in Taiwan and temporarily left the music industry Southern People Weekly, Lo Ta-yu chronology: “On December 31, held the ‘One Last Night to Warm Each Other’ farewell concert at the Taipei Arena and temporarily left the pop music scene”

March 13, 1985 Arrived in New York with his father A Date with Luyu, interview with Lo himself: “My sister had already immigrated to the United States,” and he was asked by his father to sign an immigration form; “with my father, from March 9, 1985—he took me to Japan, he knew Japan quite well, and then we stayed four days, and then on March 13, 1985, we went to New York. I still remember the dates very clearly.”

1985–1987 Lived with his sister on the U.S. East Coast The Paper, in his own words: “At the end of 1984, I decided to leave the music industry, leave Taiwan, and go to the United States. We were on the East Coast, living with my sister. In 1987, I wrote home and told my parents that I had decided to pursue music. That year, I received an invitation from Nansun Shi of Hong Kong’s Cinema City film company and went to Hong Kong to serve as music director.”

April 1, 1987 Moved to Hong Kong A Date with Luyu, interview with Lo himself: “I stayed from April 1, 1987, until roughly early 1997—yes, in fact nearly 10 years”

1992 Obtained a U.S. passport The Beijing News: “After singing ‘Phenomenon 72 Changes,’ he pulled out the U.S. passport he had obtained in ’92 and, in front of the full audience, cut up the U.S. passport”

If this timeline is accurate, then he left the United States after living there on a green card for less than 25 months and never lived in the United States long-term again, yet he obtained a U.S. passport five years after leaving the United States. This makes one wonder how Tan Youqing, who spent five anxious years trying to maintain his green card and is still agonizing over whether he can file N-400, should feel about this.

It can’t have been through military service, right? First, no media outlet has reported it. Second, GPT told me (not yet fact-checked) that the policy at the time required three years of service before naturalization, and the fast-track naturalization policy for the Gulf War did not come out until 1994, so the timeline doesn’t match up at all.

GenAI usage disclaimer: used only to search for information; the post was typed entirely by hand. Anyone who has used GPT/Claude knows it won’t help you quote such long passages from a webpage.

How did Lo Ta-yu become a U.S. citizen after living in the U.S. for only 25 months?

5
857

Comments (5)

Your avatar
Sign in to comment
JIFJKEK
JIFJKEK2 days ago

Rather than saying he naturalized after just 25 months of residence, it would be more accurate to say that those 25 months are only part of the public timeline.

接近目标
接近目标1 day ago

I'd like to ask: is it possible that between 1985 and 1987 he briefly returned to Taiwan or went somewhere else? Also, could his sister's status at the time have affected his application path? For example, family-based immigration and naturalization are two completely different tracks—if this isn't confirmed, the 25-month calculation may not even hold up.

南京势创
南京势创1 day ago

The five-year gap between obtaining a passport in 1992 and leaving the United States in 1987 may make it more important to check whether he maintained his green card and whether he re-entered the country frequently during that period than to determine how long he actually resided there; this is worth verifying further.

江南许多多
江南许多多1 day ago

A timeline doesn't necessarily have only one interpretation—don't jump to conclusions just yet.

李知励
李知励1 day ago

I'd suggest first clarifying the immigration entry and exit records and green card category from 1985 to 1987 before discussing whether 25 months is sufficient. The premise is that the dates in these interviews and reports haven't themselves been simplified—otherwise later calculations can easily go off track.