HuaRenCa
Back to Forum
Community

ChatGPT contradicts itself

转身已年华
转身已年华

2 weeks ago

I asked it whether Seattle or San Francisco is farther west, and the thing ended up contradicting itself. I had to go look it up online myself to be sure… I won't be trusting ChatGPT so readily from now on…

ChatGPT contradicts itself

7
64

Comments (7)

Your avatar
Sign in to comment
455792520
4557925202 weeks ago

Were you asking about “further west” or “smaller longitude”? It might interpret those two as different directions.

想看电影
想看电影2 weeks ago

If you only need to look something up once in a while, searching for it yourself is quick enough. But if you rely on it regularly to make decisions, it's best to cross-check every important conclusion against another source, so you don't waste more time redoing things later.

昱坤
昱坤2 weeks ago

Actually, the longitude difference between Seattle and San Francisco isn't all that big. It probably said first that Seattle is farther west, then later explained it in terms of being farther north in latitude, and ended up tying itself in knots. With this kind of geography comparison question, it often mixes different dimensions together.

无福消瘦
无福消瘦2 weeks ago

Ask someone else and you might get a different answer—how consistent it is really does come down to luck.

六月依
六月依2 weeks ago

My view is that you shouldn't rely on a single answer for this kind of factual question, since it may be logically inconsistent from one response to the next. It's best to double-check with a map or a reliable source.

头子
头子2 weeks ago

I don't think one disagreement means you should write it off entirely—after all, its strength is organizing and expressing information, not serving as an authoritative geographic database. But when it comes to hard facts like locations, numbers, and dates, you still need to stay on your guard. Especially when it sounds particularly certain, that's exactly when you should double-check.

EZSVS
EZSVS2 weeks ago

Which one did you later find out for yourself is farther west? Once you've confirmed it, you can also ask it again and see how it tries to explain itself.