HuaRenCa
Back to Forum
Community

Seeking Advice on WeGreen's Offer

弘海
弘海

2 weeks ago

Background: Dual-degree PhD student, 985 PhD in mainland China + PhD in Hong Kong.

Publications: 10, Citations: 257

Patents: 3 (all Chinese patents, first author, granted: 1 invention patent, 2 utility model patents)

Review: 4

WeGreen gave an Approval or Refund offer.

But! The precondition is that I must firmly agree to the following:

We see that you are considering to work in the industry or the private sector to pursue your proposed endeavor in the United States.

For your reference, recent statistics show a lower approval rate for industry applicants compared to researchers in academia. This is because USCIS often views private sector work as benefiting only the specific company rather than the nation.

After you graduate, we recommend pursuing a research-oriented position, preferably in academia. But if you will be working in an industrial setting, the position should involve you in research activities and continuing to publish research articles in your field of expertise, to strengthen the "national importance" argument of an EB-2 NIW petition. Do you agree to take this approach?

My current situation:

I'm about to graduate and am job hunting, considering both industry and academia. On the industry side, I may get an offer from Huawei for a user experience research position (but this role doesn't involve publishing papers). On the academic side, I'm about to start sending out applications, no offers yet.

My questions:

  1. What's the deal with WeGreen's offer? Is it really safer to work in academia?

  2. If I accept the Huawei offer, does Huawei work experience pose a risk to my immigration application? (It's not a computer science or algorithm role.)

  3. Please share your advice. If you have any other suggestions, I'd love to hear them~

5
876

Comments (5)

Your avatar
Sign in to comment
幼琴
幼琴2 weeks ago

This promise to "agree that industry should keep publishing papers too" will most likely be hard to honor at Huawei as a user researcher. When the time comes, you write a research plan in your materials, but the actual role doesn't produce papers, which makes it easy to be questioned for being inconsistent.

阚野坪
阚野坪2 weeks ago

Looked at from another angle, the key to NIW isn't academia versus industry—it's whether you can frame your work as advancing knowledge in your field or serving the public interest. Doing UX research at Huawei doesn't leave you with zero room to maneuver, but you need to find out in advance what the role's responsibilities are, what the team produces, and whether you can publish externally. If even internal reports can't be cited publicly, you'll have much thinner material to build your case on.

qingyun0818
qingyun08182 weeks ago

When you say "firmly agree," do you mean a written reply is required, or is this the default direction to take in the application materials?

揪腐败
揪腐败2 weeks ago

If you haven't signed yet, you could first apply for a round of academic positions, and at the same time clarify whether the Huawei role allows external publications and participation in research projects; once both are clear, then decide—don't agree to the law firm's terms while information is still incomplete.

尉迟2876
尉迟28762 weeks ago

Your patents are all granted in China, and two of them are utility models. Citations and patents are usually only supplementary in an NIW case. What you really need to focus on is whether the job description for the Huawei position can support a claim of "national importance," rather than simply worrying about the company itself.