HuaRenCa
Back to Forum
Community

Does getting your card shut down by Amex leave a black mark on your credit report?

乒乓友谊
乒乓友谊

2 weeks ago

It's been a year since Amex closed my card. I haven't really applied for new cards this past year, and now that I've started applying again, I've found it's no longer as smooth as it used to be. Even though my credit score has recovered to roughly where it was before the shutdown, a lot of banks no longer give instant approval. Is this account basically ruined?

5
448

Comments (5)

Your avatar
Sign in to comment
AXJ
AXJ2 weeks ago

After being shut down, were your accounts at other banks also reviewed as a result, or was it only Amex's own records? This matters for whether the damage spreads.

Magdalen
Magdalen2 weeks ago

A restored score does not mean the approval logic has been restored; the bank's internal risk model may place more weight on historical behavior.

凡华梨子
凡华梨子2 weeks ago

Actually, the bank not approving you instantly isn't necessarily because of your card-closing history—it could also be tied to the broader tightening of credit conditions lately. I've noticed that over the past year many banks have become stricter about approving non-citizens, especially applicants without a long credit history. You might first check whether this is a widespread trend before concluding it's an issue with this particular account.

雨欣
雨欣2 weeks ago

When you say "many banks don't offer instant approval," which banks specifically are you referring to? Different banks may be more or less sensitive to Amex account closures, so we need to confirm the details before we can assess the scope of the impact.

任洋
任洋2 weeks ago

Different banks have different levels of tolerance for account closures. Smaller banks may be more concerned about them, while larger banks tend to look at the overall profile.