HuaRenCa
Back to Forum
Community

When calculating benefits, it seems like people aren't factoring in insurance?

蜜桃的男人
蜜桃的男人

2 weeks ago

I've been trying to get the Amex Platinum 175k welcome offer lately (but no luck, so frustrating)

I've noticed that many high-annual-fee credit cards come with travel insurance, cell phone insurance, or rental car insurance

Cell phone insurance is probably the easiest one to actually use (as long as you're not upgrading your phone every year, you'll definitely get value from it)

If you factor in the insurance, the effective cost of holding many cards drops by $100 or more

That makes some cards that were previously hard to justify, like the Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant, suddenly worth holding

6
865

Comments (6)

Your avatar
Sign in to comment
wbjxxmy
wbjxxmy2 weeks ago

Rather than agonizing over whether you can get plaster to come out, it's better to first check your phone model and the phone insurance terms of your current card—confirm whether it's covered and what the deductible is, then decide whether it's worth opening a card for this.

dacanmao
dacanmao2 weeks ago

I think the idea of converting insurance into cash value is sound—the key is that it saves on "probabilistic expenses," not guaranteed annual cash back. If you were already planning to upgrade your phone or rent cars regularly, then that value is real; otherwise it's just good on paper while the annual fee keeps getting charged.

可霓奶奶
可霓奶奶2 weeks ago

Phone insurance usually requires you to pay the monthly fee with that card, so that's a prerequisite you need to confirm first.

人最怕坚持
人最怕坚持2 weeks ago

Rental car insurance and cell phone insurance terms vary quite a bit from state to state, especially when it comes to third-party liability and deductibles. Don't just take someone else's general summary and apply it to your own situation—it's best to check the agreement your card issuer sent you with the card.

静水港湾
静水港湾2 weeks ago

Quick question about how you worked out the phone insurance in your big-brain calculation—did you base it on the expected value of one screen repair per year, or did you just use the coverage amount for a replacement phone? Those two methods come out pretty different, and there's also the deductible and the cap on the number of claims, so I'd like to see exactly how you quantified that $100.

琦宝儿
琦宝儿2 weeks ago

Insurers can change policy terms whenever they like, so don't count on this kind of conversion rate as a long-term fixed return.