HuaRenCa
Back to Forum
Community

Can I still tax loss harvest if I hold similar stocks in my 401k?

15854361869
15854361869

2 weeks ago

I've been looking into tax loss harvesting recently,

and there's one point where I feel like I haven't found a clear definition. I'm not sure how everyone else handles it.

For example, if I tax loss harvest VOO in my taxable account, but I'm still buying VIIIX in my 401k, does that affect anything?

Looking for answers

Can I still tax loss harvest if I hold similar stocks in my 401k?

7
307

Comments (7)

Your avatar
Sign in to comment
韦小龙
韦小龙2 weeks ago

I recall the IRS has specific rules on this, but have you found the exact citation? It would be best to confirm whether wash sale rules apply only to taxable accounts or also to retirement accounts.

jjfeng626
jjfeng6262 weeks ago

The key point is that purchases inside a 401k generally don't trigger a wash sale, because the wash sale rules apply to buying a substantially identical security within 30 days after selling at a loss in a taxable account, and a 401k is usually not treated as a purchase made in your own name; that said, VOO and VIIIX track the same index, so whether they count as substantially identical is itself debatable—to be safe, spacing out the timing is the easier route.

仙辞
仙辞2 weeks ago

If you're planning to invest regularly over the long term, this move might actually end up holding you back.

Qwett
Qwett2 weeks ago

I'm not entirely convinced by the conclusion that you can just rest easy. While most interpretations hold that 401k purchases don't count, VOO and VIIIX are highly correlated, and if the IRS deems them substantially identical, the retroactive cost and hassle could be significant—especially with large amounts, it's worth consulting a tax professional.

定见
定见2 weeks ago

The real headache is the execution side: the 30-day window has to cover both before and after the sale, yet 401k payroll deductions usually buy in automatically on fixed dates, so it's hard to pause or reschedule them precisely. On top of that, dividend reinvestment can also count as a purchase, so in practice you have to factor in all of these automatic buys together.

徐克峰
徐克峰2 weeks ago

So after you sell VOO in your taxable account, how do you plan to handle your automatic investments during those 30 days?

黄金浴精品酒店
黄金浴精品酒店2 weeks ago

Look at it another way: pausing 401(k) contributions to avoid a wash sale could mean missing out on market gains, which may cost you more than it saves. First, compare the potential tax-loss benefit against the opportunity cost of pausing contributions to see which is larger.