HuaRenCa
Back to Forum
Community

If Zhuge Liang Were Given 100,000 Jin of Beef Intestines, Could the Chancellor Succeed in the Northern Expedition?

小海湾
小海湾

1 week ago

If the Chancellor had a pot of this for every soldier, I feel like they could totally steamroll Sima Yi

If Zhuge Liang Were Given 100,000 Jin of Beef Intestines, Could the Chancellor Succeed in the Northern Expedition?

7
1.3K

Comments (7)

Your avatar
Sign in to comment
Markhuang
Markhuang1 week ago

Beef intestines are a pain to preserve. Hauling grain along the Shu roads was hard enough as it was—by the time a hundred thousand catties reached the front lines, it would already be rotten. That risk is far greater than charging straight at Sima Yi.

Sophia Anderson
Sophia Anderson1 week ago

What if it's not military rations?

贺兰无双
贺兰无双1 week ago

Hold off on firing up the wok—first figure out how many ounces each person gets before you start talking about charging in.

williamtian
williamtian1 week ago

There's one thing I'd like to confirm—when you say "one pot per person," how many troops is that based on? During the Northern Expeditions, Shu Han's total military strength was only around a hundred thousand. If it really was divided as one pot per person, a hundred thousand jin of beef intestines might only last a few meals, and there'd be no way to sustain it until the standoff with Sima Yi. Looking at it another way, maybe it wasn't meant to be eaten, but rather used as city-defense supplies or as a means to disrupt the enemy army?

Sophia Anderson
Sophia Anderson1 week ago

Very likely

蔼含
蔼含1 week ago

So is this beef intestine raw or already braised? If it's raw, what kind of pot and firewood would the front line use to cook it?

kirahy
kirahy1 week ago

Just beef intestines with no staple food—you can't keep that up for long, no matter how much you eat.